Melih ("may-lee") Oztalay, CEO SmartFinds Internet Marketing Web: www.cjps-enterprises.com%3c/a> EMail: melih@hsfideas.com At CJPS Enterprises we specialize in execution. We give your company an unfair advantage.
By the time Merck withdrew Vioxx from the market in September 2004 out of concern that the pain relief drug was causing heart attacks and strokes, more than 100 million prescriptions for it had been filled in the United States alone. Researchers now estimate that Vioxx may have been associated with as many as 25,000 heart attacks and strokes. And more than 1,000 claims have been filed against the company.
Evidence of the drug's hazards was publicly available as early as November 2000, when the New England Journal of Medicine reported that four times as many patients taking Vioxx experienced myocardial infarctions as did those taking naproxen. In 2001, Merck's own report to federal regulators showed that 14.6% of Vioxx patients suffered from cardiovascular troubles while taking the drug; 2.5% developed serious problems, including heart attacks. So why, if the drug's risks had been published in 2000 and 2001, did so many doctors choose to prescribe it?
Social science research has shown that without realizing it, decision makers ignore certain critical information. Doctors, like the rest of us, are imperfect information processors. They face tremendous demands on their time and must make life-and-death decisions under highly ambiguous circumstances. In the case of Vioxx, doctors more often than not received positive feedback from patients taking the drug. And, as we now know, the Merck sales force took unethical steps to make Vioxx appear safer than it was. So despite having access to information about the risks, doctors - even those who had read the New England Journal of Medicine article - may have been blinded to the actual extent of those risks.
And why did Merck's senior executives allow the product to stay on the market for so long? Evidence points to intentional misrepresentation by the sales force, but it is quite possible that some members of Merck's top management team did not fully understand how harmful the drug was. In fact, many respected individuals have vouched for the ethics of former chairman and CEO Raymond Gilmartin, insisting that he would have pulled Vioxx from the market earlier if he had believed that it was killing people. Although senior executives are, ultimately, responsible for what happens in their organizations, the lapse here may have been more in the quality of their decision making than in any intentional unethical behavior.
In this article, we'll examine the phenomenon of bounded awareness - when cognitive blinders prevent a person from seeing, seeking, using, or sharing highly relevant, easily accessible, and readily perceivable information during the decision-making process. "The information that life serves is not necessarily the information that one would order from the menu," notes Dan Gilbert of Harvard University's psychology department, "but like polite dinner guests and other victims of circumstance, people generally seem to accept what is offered rather than banging their flatware and demanding carrots."
"Decisions Without Blinders",Max H. Bazerman and Dolly Chugh, Harvard Business Review, January 2006.
- Related Articles
- Related Q&A
- Understanding The Ambidextrous Organization
- Business Growth - Tracking Product Teams
- Business Growth - Taking A Look At Innovating For Cash
- Business Growth - Looking At Darwin And The Demon
- Business Growth - Funding Growth In An Age Of Austerity
- Business Growth - Exploring Growth Outside The Core
- Business Growth - The New Rules For Bringing Innovations To Market
- Business Growth - Examining Five Killer Strategies For Trouncing the Competition




The 8 Steps to Build Buy-in to KPIs
By: Stacey Barr | 16/11/2009You're not truly implementing performance measurement - nor getting the gains it will deliver - if you don't have your staff, your colleagues and your managers engaged. Nor do you have to wait until they are engaged before you get started!
Storage Units Create More Space For Additional Revenue
By: A.Noton | 16/11/2009Just about everyone at some time or other has wished they had more storage space. This applies to both businesses and individuals. With the present state of the economy, creating storage units or additional space can bring in extra income. Storage units can be a source of revenue for businesses...
Turan Sahinkaya Partners on Patent for Optimal Control System on Electric Motor Driven Vehicle
By: Turan Sahinkaya | 16/11/2009Turan Sahinkaya has worked with his father, Dr. Yilmaz Sahinkaya, on gaining a U.S. patent acceptance for the Optimal Control System for an Electric Motor Driven Vehicle.
Making the EXCEPTIONAL Normal Part 2 - More Benefits
By: Dale Furtwengler | 16/11/2009Six more benefits from this powerful leadership system including shared vision, better coordination, more effective workload allocation, cross training, creativity and team spirit.
Protect Your Lives Each Time You Accept Tenants
By: Barry Snyder | 16/11/2009In our lives, we always get to encounter situations when we wished we had access to important information about people. Especially if you do own a condominium or an apartment that you would want to rent out to people. Sometimes, you may be tempted to hire a private investigator to...
Save Yourself For Employment, Run a Background Check
By: Barry Snyder | 16/11/2009Unemployment really is not a desirable situation to be in. We all need money to survive, to pay our bills and to pay our food. There is no other way to earn money that to work. If you are unemployed, then you might as well take the effort and apply...
How To Find Affordable Hotels In London
By: Neron Smith | 16/11/2009No doubt that London is one of the most charming cities in the world as it has some of the famous historical sites like the Tower of London, The British Museum, The Big Ben, Westminister Abbey, etc.
FT Lauderdale Yacht Management: Choosing a Charter Yacht
By: Craig Ellyard | 16/11/2009A charter yacht can be a blissful way to spend a luxurious holiday, sailing in beautiful seas as you enjoy the splendid sunshine. But before you can enjoy any of this you have to make an important decision - which yacht are you going to charter?
Everything You Wanted To Know About Hiring
By: Melih Oztalay | 10/05/2007 | TravelHow do most luxury sedan services work? It's simple. You make a reservation, by going online or calling their local number. Drivers drive their vehicles to your home, office, or wherever you are, pick you up and take you to your destination.
Leave The Driving To Someone Else
By: Melih Oztalay | 10/05/2007 | TravelSometimes it pays to leave the driving to someone else, and it's worth paying for that option and expertise. Take a TOTAL Vacation.
A Driven Profession - The Life Of A Chauffeur
By: Melih Oztalay | 09/05/2007 | TravelWhether it's corporate or private travel, professional chauffeurs are friendly, discrete and knowledgeable driving companions who will make sure your journey is both safe and comfortable, arriving at your destination feeling refreshed and relaxed.
How To Rent A Limousine Or Luxury Sedan
By: Melih Oztalay | 09/05/2007 | TravelHiring limo or luxury sedan shouldn't be a hit-or-miss affair if you ask the right questions. First, no two limousine or luxury sedan services are the same, and different organizations place varying levels of emphasis on service as well as the investment in their fleets. You can get a clue regarding the way a company operates by how responsive they are and how professional their approach is.
Business Strategy - Conquering A Culture Of Indecision
By: Melih Oztalay | 02/05/2007 | CommunicationThe job of the CEO, everyone knows, is to make decisions. And most of them do - countless times in the course of their tenures.
Take Command of Your Growth
By: Melih Oztalay | 01/05/2007 | ManagementThe top line - like the Socratic life - demands examination. Total revenues tell a story of growth, sometimes happy, sometimes less so, but they do not tell the story of how a company grows. That knowledge abides in the distinctive wellsprings from which revenues emerge.
Stop Making Plans; Start Making Decisions
By: Melih Oztalay | 01/05/2007 | ManagementIs strategic planning completely useless? That was the question the CEO of a global manufacturer recently asked himself. Two years earlier, he launched an ambitious overhaul of the company's planning process. The old approach, which required business-unit heads to make regular presentations to the firm's executive committee, had broken down entirely.
Customer Value Propositions In Business Markets
By: Melih Oztalay | 27/04/2007 | Management'Customer value proposition' has become one of the most widely used terms in business markets in recent years. Yet our management-practice research reveals that there is no agreement as to what constitutes a customer value proposition - or what makes one persuasive.