Remember Me
forgot your password?

Recognizing the Peter Principle

"A man has got to know his limitations."
- Dirty Harry

The Peter Principle was introduced back in 1969 by Dr. Laurence J. Peter in his book of the same name. In a nutshell, the principle contends that in a hierarchical organization a person will rise to the level of their competency, and trouble arises if the person rises above it. Along with Parkinson's Law, it is one of the most well known principles in the world of management. Unfortunately, young people are unfamiliar with the concept which is perhaps why we are seeing more people lately rising above their level of competency.

So what are the earmarks of the Peter Principle? Actually, three indicators come to mind:

1. Project estimates and schedules are routinely missed. The person doesn't just miss assignments every now and then, but consistently misses them. This is indicative of the person's ability to see projects through to successful completion or manage by objectives. If he cannot, he either lacks the proper skills and training to perform the work, or simply doesn't care about being late or over budget.

2. The duties and responsibilities as defined in a job description are not being met. Again, this may be indicative of the lack of proper knowledge, skills and experience, or an attitude problem.

3. The person lacks the respect and confidence of the people working around him, not only his subordinates, but his superior and lateral relationships as well. Although this is difficult to quantify, it basically tells us, "Where there is smoke, there is fire." In other words, the person either has bad social skills, or his peers already know what he is capable and incapable of doing.

Aside from dealing with someone who is in over his head, the real challenge is to hire the right person for the right job, which is not quite as easy as it may sound. Human resource departments may have a battery of tests to verify a person's skills and general knowledge, but successful experience and attitudes are much harder to substantiate. Again, there are three areas to consider:

1. Ability to meet project estimates and schedules. This is difficult to demonstrate and management inevitably has to rely on the person's word for their performance. Then again, if the person had been using a Project Management system at his last job, he may have access to documentation which reflects his performance.

2. Understands the job he is applying for. This is where a lot of people get into trouble as they do not really grasp the significance of the job they are applying for, but like the title. Regretfully, people too often chase titles as opposed to jobs. To test his knowledge, ask the person to articulate the job description and how he would satisfy the requirements for it. Further, has he performed a comparable job like this before?

3. Respect of the people he worked with. Again, this is difficult to substantiate as people are more reluctant to give references these days in fear of possible litigation for giving a bad reference. Nonetheless, references should be scrutinized as closely as possible.

The one question that is commonly overlooked is, "Why do you want this job?" The answers might surprise you, e.g.; "I need a job", "I'm looking to advance myself and need a challenge," "I'm the right person for the job", etc. The one I particularly like is, "I want to make a difference," which indicates to me the person's confidence and ambition.

Hiring people without doing a thorough examination of the person's background is courting the Peter Principle.

Allowing people to stay in a position where they are in over their head is just plain irresponsible on management's part. It is a disservice not only to the company, but to the employee as well. When a person has risen above their level of competency, it will become obvious to others and may affect morale. Standard and routine performance appraisals should help overcome this problem, but if they are infrequently performed or done in an inconsistent manner, the Peter Principle will inevitably kick in. Management should either work with the person to get him back on track, or terminate his employment.

I guess what troubles me here is that people apply for jobs they knowingly are not qualified for, and remarkably, every now and then they slip through the cracks and get the job. In this event, management gets what they pay for.

If you would like to discuss this with me in more depth, please do not hesitate to send me an e-mail.

Keep the faith.

Tim Bryce

Tim Bryce is a writer and management consultant with M. Bryce & Associates of Palm Harbor, Florida and has over 30 years of experience in the field. He is available for lecturing, training and consulting on an international basis. He can be reached at timb001@phmainstreet.com
Comments and questions are welcome.


His writings can be found at:

http://www.phmainstreet.com/timbryce.htm


Copyright © 2008 by Tim Bryce. All rights reserved.

Rate this Article: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s)
Print Email Re-Publish

Add new Comment



Captcha

  • Latest Management Articles
  • More from Tim Bryce

Newbury Park Acura Service

By: Weldon Duffy | 16/12/2009
If you're the proud owner of a Honda or an Acura, you wish to keep it running and looking as new for so long as you can. The easiest way to do that's by finding an automotive repair center that focuses on Honda and Acura service and repair[**]. Finding a repair center that will offer you and your automobile with service beyond compare may appear too good to be true but it's's not, and Westlake Independent Honda/Acura Service is a perfect example. people are holding on to their...

How to get an ISO 9001 Accreditation

By: Naresh Shah | 16/12/2009
There are many benefits for a company to have an ISO 9001 accreditation and the most important being that it gives a great impression of the business. If companies are planning to tender for a contract with a Local Authority for example, it can be one of the required criteria.

Accidents At Work: Top 7 Facts About UK Work Accident Statistics

By: Jessica A Parker | 16/12/2009
Accidents at work happen every day in the UK, and the latest statistics from the Health and Safety Executive for 2008/9 show just how many and what type of work accidents have been reported by British workers in the last year. Here are the top 7 facts about the 2008/9...

Visualization Saves Your Meeting

By: Olesya Gileva | 16/12/2009
According to research, most project specialists take part in 62 meetings a month and approximately half of this time is considered to be nonproductive. If we deem that each meeting lasts for one hour, then most project specialists lose 31 hours every month in unproductive meetings, nearly 4 full working days a month. When looking at these statistics, it is not surprising that meetings have such a bad reputation.

Online Party Registration Services Diminish Hurdles of a Christmas Party

By: Article Manager | 16/12/2009
If you want to make your Christmas party memorable, then it is advised to go with an online Christmas party registration service provider as it is proficient enough to create, manage, promote and sell tickets for an event.

Green Christmas Events No More a Distant Dream

By: Article Manager | 16/12/2009
The Green Christmas event can now be promoted to the global clientele. This Christmas season protect Mother Earth with small, yet substantial effort while inviting all your friends and loved ones through online channel.

Renewable Energy Certificates in North America

By: Bharat Book Bureau | 16/12/2009
Bharatbook.com added a new report on "Renewable Energy Certificates in North America" which gives Benefits and Barriers to Renewable Energy Certificates Market Development in North America.

System Misconceptions

By: Tim Bryce | 08/12/2009 | Management
What it is not.

A Curriculum for Social Skills

By: Tim Bryce | 24/11/2009 | Human Resources
Discusses three prime areas of concentration to improve social skills.

Differences between East and West

By: Tim Bryce | 24/11/2009 | Team Building
Discusses cultural differences between offices in Japan and the United States.

Why Project Management Fails

By: Tim Bryce | 21/10/2009 | Management
Four reasons why project management breaks down.

The Problem with "Man Hours"

By: Tim Bryce | 16/09/2009 | Project Management
I've never been comfortable with the concept of "Man Hours," not that it's a gender issue, but rather it implies ignorance of how time is used in the work place and fumbles away some simple management concepts needed to run any business, namely accountability and commitment. Actually, I thought the "Man Hour" concept disappeared with the passing of the 20th century, but it appears to be making a comeback.

Humor in the Work Place

By: Tim Bryce | 31/08/2009 | Management
When and how humor should be injected in the work place.

Software Versions and Releases

By: Tim Bryce | 31/08/2009 | Software
Are the words synonymous? Can they be used interchangeably?

Challenging the Status Quo

By: Tim Bryce | 28/08/2009 | Management
Stagnation is not an option.

Submit Your Articles Free: Signup
Article Categories




Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (0.30, 6, w1)