How to Botch a Home Loan Application: An Example from Owner Builder Construction Loans

Getting a loan pre-approval from a lender is a quick, easy process. Typically, you fill out a few pages about your financial situation, the bank runs the numbers through a computer approval system, and you're pre-approved the next day.

So, how do so many people mess it up so badly? Simply put, people lie (either to themselves or about themselves) when filling out a loan application.

We'll look at examples from customers who applied for owner builder construction loans, but the principles of filling out a home loan application will apply equally well to anyone who wants a loan to buy or refinance a home.

Owner builder construction loans are for individuals who wish to build their own house without having to hire a general contractor. Therefore, they manage the sub-contractors themselves and oversee the project.

However, an owner builder loan application is no different from a standard purchase loan or refinance loan application. Almost every bank across the country will use a form known as a Uniform Residential Loan Application, also known as a 1003.

On this 4 or 5 page form, you simply fill in information about your financial situation. On the first page, you'll cover simple info about the property as well as information about your address, phone, social security number, etc.

The second page will cover your work history and income. The third page will cover your assets and your monthly debts. All in all, the process is not difficult. In fact, anyone, whether you are an owner builder or someone looking to refinance an existing home, can fill it out without too much difficulty.

Therefore, the mistakes that are seen on owner builder loan applications be due to reasons other than misunderstandings. Indeed, almost every mistake occurs when an owner builder decides to embellish his qualifications or thinks it's unimportant to be as accurate as possible.

You may be asking yourself why it's such a big deal. Why should you care if you round off your numbers on the application? After all, it's just a pre-approval. The bank will collect all of the real paperwork later on.

Here's an example from a recent owner builder loan. A loan applicant decided the pre-approval was not worth his time to provide detailed information about his financial situation. He rounded up his income and failed to mention the child support payments that he is obligated to make each month.

In the case of this owner builder, the application was pre-approved quickly and easily. Why wouldn't it be? On paper, everything looked great. But, when the bank started collecting the official income documentation and discovered the child support payments being deducted from the pay stubs, the borrower no longer qualified for the loan.

Not a big deal, right? Wrong. This owner builder had already put money down on a piece of land that he wanted to buy as well as purchased blueprints for his new home he wanted to build. Imagine the frustration and anger he caused himself when he found he was no longer qualified for the loan and he lost the money he wasted on blueprints.

Even though this is an example from owner builder construction, it still applies to anyone filling out a Uniform Residential Loan Application. Imagine you are buying a home and make a large earnest money deposit on the house you want based on getting pre-approved from your bank. Now imagine that your pre-approval is based on inaccurate information that you told the bank. In fact, imagine that you also wasted money out of your pocket for the home inspection and the appraisal.

So, what can you do? Whether you are looking for an owner builder construction loan or any other type of mortgage: tell the truth.

Do not think that embellishing your financial picture will help. It will only hurt you in the long run when the lender discovers the errors. You are better off getting an accurate pre-approval based on accurate information.

And, if you are unsure about your exact income numbers or your exact amount of assets, then estimate conservatively. That way, if your income or assets turn out to be higher than you estimated, you will still be approved and qualified for the loan program you are counting on. It works for owner builder construction loans. It works for refinances. It works for home purchases. It works.

In fact, one great piece of advice is to supply copies of your W2 forms, your pay stubs, and your asset statements when getting your pre-approval. Many customers, not just owner builder customers, don't want to take the time to do this, because it's a hassle. But, your loan officer can use these documents to ensure the pre-approval is based on accurate calculations. Besides, you are going to have to submit these documents for underwriting anyway.

For example, a recent owner builder borrower took the time to submit his pay stubs when he applied for his construction loan. A big portion of his income came from bonus pay. It turned out that he could only get credit for the average of his bonus pay over the last two years, in addition to his full base salary. Therefore, his gross income was calculated slightly lower for the loan that he thought it would have been.

In this case, the owner builder fortunately still qualified for the construction loan. However, you can see how miscalculating income can lead your pre-approval to be inaccurate. Therefore, don't take any chances. Submit your documentation paperwork when you fill out the application.

So, if you are thinking of applying anytime soon for a mortgage for a home purchase or a simple refinance, then take a lesson from the world of owner builder construction loans. Do not discount the importance of providing accurate information about your financial situation on the Uniform Residential Loan Application. The pre-approval is a quick and easy process, but it's also a very important one. Owner builder construction loans are no different in this respect.