Mortgage Security not That Costly

Author: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence

| Posted: 11-01-2007 | Comments: 0 | Views: 273 | Rating: (145)

(?)

Forget everything you thought you knew about the benefits of taking a variable-rate mortgage instead of locking in for the long term.

A new study suggests the security of a five-year mortgage costs little or nothing beyond a riskier variable-rate mortgage, providing you get a jumbo-sized rate discount.

"Interest costs on discounted closed five-year mortgages have been close to, and often lower than, those of variable-rate mortgages since late 1996," senior Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. economist Ali Manouchehri writes in the study.

Homeowners have made variable-rate mortgages hugely popular in the past few years in the belief that you can save on interest costs by pegging your mortgage rate to your lender's prime lending rate. As the prime rises, or as has generally happened in the past few years, fallen, so goes your mortgage rate.

The prime rate at the major banks is now 4.5 per cent, while the posted five-year rate at the big banks is 6.15 per cent. In just one year, the variable-rate choice would save you about $1,700 on monthly payments toward a $150,000 mortgage amortized over 25 years (assuming a level prime rate).

Historically, you would also have saved a lot. The CMHC study shows that five-year mortgages taken out from 1993 through 1998 would have cost anywhere from $50,000 to $5,000 in additional interest paid over the term of the loan (the example is based on a $100,000 mortgage amortized over 25 years).

The flaw with this analysis is that it doesn't reflect real-world mortgage pricing. These days, very few people take out a mortgage without a sizable discount off the posted rates at major banks.

For that reason, the CMHC's Mr. Manouchehri decided to compare discounted five-year mortgages with discounted variable-rate mortgages. Incidentally, five years is the most popular term by far for fixed-rate mortgages at about 59 per cent of the total.

The size of the discounts Mr. Manouchehri applied was based on the difference between posted major bank rates and the best deals available from other lenders. For five-year mortgages, he used a discount of 1.25 of a percentage point; for variable-rate mortgages, it was 0.4 of a point off prime.

For five-year mortgages taken out between 1993 and mid-1996, the five-year mortgage was costlier in terms of interest costs. Since then, however, variable-rate mortgages have generally been a little bit more expensive.

Obviously, there's nothing in this study that decides the fixed-rate versus variable-rate debate once and for all.

In fact, the CMHC study may just confuse anyone who recalls some research done for Manulife Financial back in 2000 by York University finance professor Moshe Milevsky. His research found that the extra interest charged on a five-year mortgage would have cost $20,000 on average between 1950 and 2000 for a $100,000 mortgage amortized over 15 years.

To make some sense of the variable-rate versus five-year question, let's go back to the CMHC study.

It shows that five-year mortgages, discounted or otherwise, were especially bad choices for a three-year period starting in mid-1993. Rates were high for a while back then, but they subsequently fell.

You were a spectator to these rate declines if you were stuck in a five-year mortgage, while people in variable-rate mortgages would have benefited almost immediately.

It's a different world now, though. Five-year mortgage rates are close to a 50-year low, which suggests they're far more likely to rise over their term than fall.

So what's the best choice here, variable-rate or five-year fixed rate? People who want to pay rock-bottom mortgage rates for as long as possible will probably still want a variable-rate mortgage. Remember, you can lock this sort of mortgage into a fixed term without penalty in most cases.

The case for the five-year term looks almost as strong, though. First, the CMHC study tells us there may not be a significant cost to locking your mortgage in for five years, and you might even save a little over a variable-rate mortgage.

Second, the likelihood of higher rates in the years to come would suggest that this is a good time to lock in.

If you had a variable-rate mortgage discounted to 4 per cent, the prime would have to go up by 0.85 of a percentage point to equal the current five-year rate. That's not a lot of ground to cover in the span of 12 to 18 months when the economy is doing well.

Arguably, the variable-rate versus fixed-rate debate is all about risks and rewards. Right now, the five-year option offers much less risk, and almost as much reward.

Rate this Article:

Current: 5 / 5 stars - 2 vote(s).

Article Tags: Mortgage, Finance, Money, How To, Debt, Mortgage Broker, Mortgage Company, Ontario Mortgage Rates, Ontario Mortgage

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/mortgage-articles/mortgage-security-not-that-costly-91034.html

Print article

Send to friend

Publish this Article

Author feedback

About the Author:

The House Team is commited to providing quality information to help people make informed decisions about their mortgage financing needs.

Compare Ontario Mortgage Rates with the traditional banks.

Need a mortgage calculator? Click Here Mortgage Calculator Ontario

Mortgage Rates Ontario

Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free!

Article Comments

Add new Comment

Taking the Guesswork Out of Adjustable Rate Mortgages
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Mortgage
Next to critiquing the decorating taste of your home's previous owner, playing the "adjustable mortgage game" may rank as one of the most popular (and least pleasant) pastimes of Canadian homebuyers.

Homeowners are Taking Out Mortgages - not to Purchase a Home - But to Boost Their Purchasing Power
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Mortgage
Real estate has been an outstanding investment in most parts of Canada in the past few years. Home valuations are continuing to rise and have broken through the peak of their 1989 "bubble" in many areas of the country.

Your Mortgage Could be a Goldmine of Potential Savings
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Finance
"A penny saved is a penny earned"... or so the old proverb goes. Of course, the value of a penny has changed somewhat from the time when your mother offered her wisdom on the value of keeping what you earn. Today, you could save thousands of dollars by simply making the right mortgage decision.

Clearing the Downpayment Hurdle is Easier Than Ever
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Mortgage
Buy a house with no money down! We feel intuitively that it can't possibly be true. But this year, watch for a fresh crop of promotions for mortgages available with little or no downpayment.

How to Use a Mortgage to Manage your Debt and Improve your Credit
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Mortgage
What if there was such a thing as a magic card that you could carry with you, which had the power to open doors for you all over the world? You show someone your magic card and 'voila', you can have what you wish for. You would want to protect that card very carefully, wouldn't you? Your credit is a little like that.

First-time Homebuyer? your Rrsp May be the Downpayment You're Looking for
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Mortgage
Thinking about buying your first home? Wish you had saved up a good downpayment? Maybe you have, but didn't know it.

Make a Mortgage Broker Part of your Financial Plan
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Mortgage
For most Canadians, buying a home is the largest financial decision they will make in their lifetime. Yet, consumers across the country are more likely to painstakingly review dozens of investment possibilities for their portfolios than to scrutinize their mortgage choices.

Pick the Right Perks for your Adjustable Rate Mortgage
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Mortgage
These are heavy days for Canadian homeowners. If you've been in your home even a few years, you've probably already enjoyed a modest climb in the value of your home.

Got a Question? Ask.

Ask the community a question about this article:

Frequently Asked Questions

Is flashing always used on the gable edge of a ...
By: billdm | 20-07-2008
Is flashing always used on the gable edge of a roof to seal it or protect it from leaking?

Air conditoner
By: marguerite | 20-07-2008
The central air unit is working but the air conditioner unit outside is not coming on (fan) What could be the problem? We check the circuit breaker and it is fine.

New fountain
By: fountain | 20-07-2008
Im trying to install a a six foot fountain the old style with a (cantera) at the bottom im looking for a box to put in the pump. Not sure to put it inside the cantera or out side

Cooling capacity
By: Paul Castonguay | 20-07-2008
What size unit do I need for a 1350 sq ft manufactured home?

I have a bargain store in holiday fl, my partner ...
By: frankie | 20-07-2008
i have a bargain store in holiday fl, my partner gamble all the money away i am sitting in a empty store i need money to obtain product for my store can u help?

Circuit breaker closes before dishwasher finishes
By: allenman | 20-07-2008
circuit breaker closes before dishwasher finishes

Q&A Powered by:

Latest Mortgage Articles

Credit Crunch Creates a New Stay at Home Generation
By: Christian Ward | 26/07/2008
You will most likely be aware of the problems in the mortgage market as of late. With the credit crunch making it harder for everybody to manage anyway, those trying to get onto the property ladder have to get at the back of a very long queue to start climbing.

Where Do You Go for a Mortgage Comparison?
By: Aaron Hill | 25/07/2008
To get a good mortgage comparison it is important to look behind the headline figures and get a wider choice than is available through the big names in the High Street. Although the Internet may help, it is best to consult a mortgage broker or advisor who can understand your individual requirements.

Mortgage Timebomb in Retirement
By: Christian Ward | 25/07/2008
Are UK homeowners heading towards a £207 billion mortgage debt time-bomb in retirement?

Mortgage Repayments and Lowering Them
By: Christian Ward | 25/07/2008
A standard variable rate mortgage (which is SVR for short) is the standard borrowing rate offered by loan companies. It has a tendency to mimic the Bank of England Base Rate, moving higher and lower a long with it. Loan providers will most often charge 1% or 2% beyond the Base Rate as their SVR. This suggests that should the Base rate goes higher, so also will your mortgage rates, hence the term 'variable' due to the fact that your instalments can vary.

Mortgage Crunch and Surviving it
By: Christian Ward | 25/07/2008
Those hunting out a mortgage have seen a sudden change over the past six months from a land of plenty to a time of drought.

Home Mortgage Refinancing - Why Should I Refinance?
By: Alan Lim | 25/07/2008
Here are a few informational hints that may help you determine if home mortgage refinancing is the route for you to follow. A discussion of why and when refinancing is helpful follows.

Home Mortgage Loan - Tips for Reviewing Loans
By: Alan Lim | 25/07/2008
Once your have begun the process of obtaining a home mortgage loan, here are some essential things to watch or watch out for in reviewing loan proposals and documents.

A Lesson in Time for Owner Builder Loans
By: Chris Esposito | 24/07/2008
Owner builders need to understand the owner builder loan and planning timeline before they make an offer on the land they want. Do these things in the right order, and you'll be well prepared for success. Owner builders who jump blindly into the process will set themselves up for disaster.

More from The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence

Downsizing Your Home, Expanding Your Options
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 01/04/2008 | Moving and Relocating
Once the kids have grown and moved out, it often makes less sense to hold onto a big home. Ongoing maintenance costs and taxes may be difficult to justify when only one or two people are occupying the home.

7 Reasons to Use a Mortgage Broker
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 01/04/2008 | Mortgage
For many people, mortgage payments are their single largest expense. Yet, when financing a home, most Canadians don’t comparison shop to ensure they’re getting the best mortgage rate and terms available. This mistake can cost homeowners tens of thousands of dollars over the course of their mortgage.

5 Steps to Making Your Dream Renovation a Reality
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 01/04/2008 | Home Improvement
The lure of a stunning gourmet kitchen or sparkling spa-style bathroom may have you chomping at the bit to begin a home renovation. But if you heed the advice of experienced renovators, pre-planning and advanced preparation are the secrets to renovation success. Here’s a helpful checklist to get your renovation started on the right track

Is a Recreation Property Right for You?
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 28/03/2008 | Real Estate
Whether it's called a cottage, a chalet or a country house, the lure of a recreation property far from the hustle of the city is too much for many of us to resist.

Trading Up? Tips to Get Into That Next Home Faster
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 28/03/2008 | Real Estate
The resale housing market is expected to remain at near record sales levels in 2008, according to The Canadian Real Estate Association.

Belleville's House Team - One of Canada's Best
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 18/01/2007 | Press Releases
Local mortgage broker Peter House also named to national awards shortlist for Canada’s Broker of the Year

Mortgage "stores" are a Hit With Homebuyers
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Mortgage
Okay, that may have been an easy one if you read the headline of this column. For most Canadians, their home is their biggest investment - and their most powerful financial tool.

Fixed or Variable-rate Mortgage?
By: The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence | 11/01/2007 | Mortgage
"Wow!" you say to your spouse as you hit the brakes on the car. "Did you see the mortgage rate those guys are advertising?" Your worries are over, you're thinking. Just lock in a rate like that for the next ten years, and you've got it made.

Article Categories

Article Marketing

Article Notepad

Stop Duplicate Content

Term Papers

Need Help?

Sign up for our email newsletter

Receive updates, enter your email below

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (0.19, 17)

Mortgage Security not That Costly

Article Comments

Related Articles

Got a Question? Ask.

Latest Mortgage Articles

More from The House Team Of Mortgage Intellingence

Need Help?

Site Links

Webmasters

Business Info

Sign up for our email newsletter