William F. Nimmo is a highly regarded San Diego criminal defense attorney who has successfully defended residents statewide for nearly three decades. He has been a San Diego criminal trial lawyer of the year and has been awarded the Directors' Award for Excellence by the San Diego Criminal Defense Bar Association. See http://www.nimmolawgroup.com/ for more information.
Reducing murder to manslaughter is a task that presents itself in many murder cases. Depending on your state or jurisdiction you may be able to reduce murder to manslaughter by eliminating the element of "malice." Classically, this is where the defendant acts by being provoked into a sudden quarrel or into a state of mind known as the "heat of passion." The mental state of "heat of passion" is not just one emotion. It can be anger, jealously, or any other agitated state of mind in the normal range of human behavior.
If a person is intentionally killed but the defendant was provoked or was in the heat of passion due to some provocative circumstance of the alleged victim, the killing is said to be mitigated to voluntary manslaughter. The defendant cannot just set up his or her own standard of conduct. The situation causing the heat of passion must be such that a reasonable person under the circumstances would have been provoked to act out of passion rather than logic. The classic example given in law schools is where a person comes home unexpectedly and finds their spouse in bed with another person. This is the type of act that could cause any reasonable person to act out of passion and emotion rather than logic.
Usually these cases happen in times of great stress and emotion and a psychologist or psychiatrist should be employed to see if any factors of the mental state of the defendant or victim can be used to reduce the offense to manslaughter. How mental state factors can be used depend upon the laws of the jurisdiction in which the case is being tried.
If it can be shown that the killing was unintentional, but reckless, in some states the case can be reduced to involuntary manslaughter. Involuntary manslaughter carries a significantly lower penalty than voluntary manslaughter. Sometimes what looks like a murder, an intentional killing, is really an accident under extremely stressful circumstances. Note that in some states an unintentional killing, if extreme enough, can be murder. Generally that type of act must be more than recklessness. Typically, to make an unintentional act murder there must exist a callous disregard for human life. In some states those types of acts are called "depraved heart murders."
As an example, a female was charged with murder when she stabbed her husband in the chest with a steak knife. They were in the kitchen making dinner and got into an argument. Because the knife hit a major artery near the heart, he died within minutes. The defendant told two different stories about what happened. She said it was an accident and she didn't mean to kill him. She was prosecuted for murder and taken to trial.
The defense noticed that the location and angle of the wound seemed odd for an intentional stabbing. The blade went in at an angle rather than vertical. This didn't seem consistent with how a person intentionally stabbing another would have stabbed. Also, the blade went right between the ribs in a soft area of cartilage. It seemed unlikely that a non professional could have known this vulnerability and hit it so precisely.
The defense retained a well-known pathologist who totally agreed and testified that all of the circumstances were consistent with an accident and inconsistent with patterns of known stabbings. A psychiatrist also testified to the woman's exaggerated startle response because of beatings from a prior relationship. The defense theory was that she accidentally stabbed her boyfriend when he quickly advanced towards her in the argument. She over-reacted and, without consciously knowing it, thrust her knife hand forward. The knife went through the butter-soft cartilage and pierced the artery. The jury found her not guilty of murder and found her guilty of involuntary manslaughter. Had she not been under the influence of drugs, the jury might have found the act to be a pure accident and totally excused her.
To show that a killing is either voluntary manslaughter or involuntary manslaughter, a thorough investigation, analysis, and reconstruction is mandated. Even if the act was not the type that would justify reducing a murder to manslaughter, the fact that the defendant was in the heat of passion could eliminate premeditation and deliberation and reduce the degree of the murder.
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A




Finding Answers: Identity Theft Solution
By: Christopher S. Norwood | 07/01/2010In days gone by if an individual had been the victim of a theft they would have known right away. This is because the thief would generally steal tangible items. Those items could have included stereos, televisions, jewelry, money, etc. However, today, not only are tangible items stolen, but intangible items as well. Specifically, one of those intangible items that can be stolen is a person's identity.
Speeding Ticket Victory, Traffic court Strategy and Tactics
By: charles belle | 06/01/2010A case study of a real and authentic speeding case in traffic court and the defedants victory without a lawyer
A Good Advice on California Trust Beneficiary
By: Vivek Kushwaha | 06/01/2010People die. No one is immortal. When you’re a kid, you don’t think about your parents dying, money spending, and other things that once end.
Arbitration in Construction Contracts in India
By: Azeez Nazar Sabri | 05/01/2010In the Construction contracts, where the huge money involves, an early and inexpensive dispute resolution is required otherwise the project will run in time overrun resulting into the huge losses of money.Though Mediation and Conciliation is very inexpensive mode of dispute resolution mechanism but the decision of the Mediator and Conciliator are not enforceable.Arbitration is also one of the Alternative Dispute Resolution modes,more effective than Other Modes of ADR.
How To Beat A Ticket
By: Larry Kearney | 02/01/2010How to beat a ticket before your court date. Would you like to know how to beat a ticket in 8 easy steps? Read our free report to get the details.
Child Custody Rights - Fighting For Child Custody? Read This!
By: Alan Katz | 31/12/2009When a parent is fighting for custody of their child or children, they can become emotionally overwhelmed causing them confusion whilst wondering what exactly their child custody rights are or will be.
The EB-5 Immigrant Investor Visa: What is it and how is it attained?
By: MFrizzi | 30/12/2009The EB-5 Immigrant Investor Visa is one of the easiest and most flexible routes an immigrant can take if they are interested in gaining a United States green card. These visas are contingent on an investment being made in the United States along with the creation, either directly or indirectly, of a set amount of jobs.
Our Government is Out of Control
By: Ralph E. Bass, Jr. | 28/12/2009I believe our government is out of control. Is there a means to bring back our government into line with our historic American political and economic values? I believe there is if the American people will insist on a new bill of rights, or as I call this Constitutional amendment, The Bill of Freedom.
Criminal Defense Lawyers: Reducing Murder to Manslaughter
By: William F. Nimmo | 08/05/2006 | National, State, LocalThis article explains how to reduce a murder to manslaughter in a criminal court case.
The Credentials of Any Good San Diego Criminal Defense Lawyer
By: William F. Nimmo | 04/04/2006 | LawThis article explains the credentials of any good San Diego criminal defense lawyer.