Over the past few decades there have been many preventive measures implemented to reduce the risks of drunk driving. The courts and motor vehicle departments have used traditional countermeasures such as fines, jail terms, and license suspensions to control drunk driving offenders. Now there are instruments like the ignition interlock device (IID) that are being used as punishment. However, the question that lawmakers have been asking is: How effective is the IID? Has it indeed lowered the reoccurrences of drunk driving in repeat offenders?
IIDs are instruments installed in automobiles that measure the alcohol on a driver’s breath. The driver provides a breath sample and if the IID detects alcohol, the car will not start. IIDs were developed and have been researched since the 1960s, however, it wasn’t until recently that these instruments have been used and accepted by the courts. California was the first state to enact legislation that authorized judges to order DUI offenders to install IIDs. California was also the first state in which the ignition interlock program was evaluated.
There have been a few studies in various states to determine whether or not IIDs are effective in reducing DUIs. The results of these studies have been mixed, although most of the results suggested that IIDs have reduced DUI reoccurrences in offenders. That’s only if the instrument remains in the car. However, once the IID is removed from the car, the chances of another DUI incident occurring goes back up. This suggests that IIDs are not going to actually change people’s behavior. It only prevents them from driving their own car when they’re drunk. They’re going to continue to drink whether or not the instrument is installed.
In September 2005 a study released by the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) in California concluded that IIDs can be effective at reducing the occurrence of subsequent DUIs. Unfortunately, judges have not always ordered DUI offenders to install an IID in their car. Technically, the IID is effective, but it’s the actual program that is not effective.
Based on the results of this September 2005 study, the researchers offered these recommendations to improve the program:
1. An improved monitoring system for DUI offenders ordered by judges to install an IID. It’s important for the courts to be consistent because installing the device does have a significant effect in reducing DUIs.
2. Allow second DUI offenders the chance to reinstate their driver’s license if they install the IID in their vehicle. This gives repeat offenders incentive to put in the device if the court does not mandate it. Another way to encourage offenders to install an IID is to reduce the period of license suspension.
3. Impound the vehicle of a person who is caught without an IID in their car. This applies to those people restricted to driving an IID-equipped vehicle.
4. Investigate the barriers to the use of the IID and find more effective programs to implement these devices. The DMV should have the responsibility of leading this task force and finding the resources to fund it.
5. Do not emphasize the use of the IID for first-time offenders. Currently there is no evidence that the device is effective at reducing the reoccurrence of a DUI in first-time offenders.
6. Continue to support the law that requires judges to order DUI offenders to install the IID in their vehicle.
The ignition interlock device is not going to be the key to completely wipe out drunk driving. However, preventative measures combined with consistent action is a step in the right direction.
Related Articles
Do I Need A DUI Lawyer?
By: Gray Rollins | 02/02/2006 | Law
You've been arrested on a DUI charge. Now what do you do? Although most people will recommend that you hire a lawyer to represent your best interests many people do not do so, often because of shame and embarrassment.
A Staggering Statistics of Teenage Drunk Driving
By: andy taylor | 25/05/2008 | National, State, Local
Statistics show that approximately 70% of all teenagers drink alcohol, including 1 out of 10 children between the ages of 12 and 13.
Should Underage Drinking be Allowed for Active Duty Military?
By: Maria Palma | 14/03/2008 | News and Society
There's been quite a bit of talk about lowering the drinking age limit for people who serve in the military. The argument posed is that these people are young enough to shoot guns, serve and die for the U.S., so why not allow them to drink legally?
6 Ways to Stop Drunk Driving
By: Maria Palma | 16/03/2008 | Culture
Drunk driving has been an ongoing issue not only the U.S., but in many areas around the world. Various organizations have tried different things to prevent drunk driving, but this problem keeps going on and on.
What It The Penalty For A DUI?
By: Gray Rollins | 03/04/2006 | Law
DUI Penalties It is important to protect yourself from arrests due to driving under the influence. The best possible way to avoid this is to not get behind the wheel of a car if you have been drinking.
Should Dui Offenders’ Names be Published in the Media?
By: Maria Palma | 18/03/2008 | National, State, Local
What if your name and face was all over the media because you were charged with a DUI? Would you then think twice about drinking and driving?
When You Need A DUI Lawyer
By: Hege Crowton | 26/04/2006 | Law
Despite the fact that Americans have been campaigning against drunk driving since the early eighties, there are still those who excuse themselves from breaking such a serious law. For this reason, police are constantly vigilant for those who may be operating a vehicle under the influence.
How to Prevent a Wrongful Dui Conviction
By: Maria Palma | 12/07/2008 | National, State, Local
If you’ve been stopped for drinking and driving, it can be an embarrassing situation. However, if you’ve had only one drink and you think that you’re ok, there’s no need to stress out. There have been cases, though, in which a person was pulled over by the police and was arrested even though they weren’t over the legal limit for drinking.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do i have an arraignment date after i got off probation
By: Hello Princess | 30-07-2008
i recently got off probation for a dui. and i just checked my records in the clerk of courts and it said that i had an arraignment date on the 28th of this month, no one contacted me or told me.. is this something they normally do, and i dont need to be present. or was that something i shouldve gone to. please help
Been to court 4 times, when can i get my case dismissed?
By: sarah | 29-07-2008
I was arrested on October 7, 2007 for a DUI. I have been to court 4 times already, each time the judge has told me my case was not filed yet and to come back in 3 months. How long can this go on? Can I get my case dismissed after a year of my arrest date, and if so how do I go about doing that?
Is there any hope after the three years to even ...
By: mike | 28-07-2008
is there any hope after the three years to even find a job using your cdl?
I have a dui in 1986 another in 1987 . currently I ...
By: Hudson | 28-07-2008
I have a dui in 1986 another in 1987 . currently I have no points against my license . can I get a cdl?
Dwi removal off record
By: Ken Sosa | 27-07-2008
Does anyone know the best route to get a class b misdemeanor dwi expunged or pardoned from your record?
Dui conviction
By: LADY32 | 24-07-2008
Can you still be hired as a commercial driver after being convicted of a DUI?
Q&A Powered by:
Latest National, State, Local Articles
The Most Common Mistake Lawyers Make When Sending a Lawsuit to a Registered Agent
By: Marti Talbott | 03/09/2008
There is nothing more frustrating than to complete a lawsuit, file it with the court and send it off to the intended recipient - only to have it returned because of a silly and avoidable mistake.
International Human Rights: Prescription and Enforcement
By: Utsav Kumar | 03/09/2008
This article talks about international human rights and the requirement of it to get enforced and the way to get it enforced.
Fundamental Duties
By: juhi aggarwal | 03/09/2008
this is an article remiding the citizens of india about their fundamental duties..!!
Freedom of Speech and Expression
By: Suneera Nerissa Madhok | 03/09/2008
To give to all citizens of India a complete insight into one of our most inherent and crucial rights also a Fundamental Right under the Constitution of India- The Freedom of Speech & Expression
Illinois Suspended License Law
By: David J. Shestokas | 02/09/2008
Driving on a suspended license is at least a Class “A” misdemeanor, (in some situations it may be a felony with possible prison time). It is different from an ordinary traffic ticket. Tickets such as speeding, disobeying a stop sign or stop light, or failing to signal are referred to as petty offenses. These are not criminal matters, and can be punished generally only by a fine.
EPCs Required For Buy To Let Investments
By: Karl Hopkins | 02/09/2008
From Oct 2008 Energy Performance Certificates (EPCs) will be added to the documentation buy to let investors will be required to provide tenants. The Certificates will cost in the region of 100 pounds, and will be valid for up to ten years.
The Problem of “prostitution” an Indian Perspective
By: Kaustubh Nanada Sinha | 02/09/2008
The article deals with the problem of prostitution in India and shall we legalize prostitution or make laws which not only efficient but also effective.
New Thai Law Streamlines Consumer Complaints
By: Gregory Smyth | 02/09/2008
A new Thai law will soon streamline the process of making complaints for consumers, as August 23 marks the beginning of effectiveness of the Consumer Case Procedures Act. We look at the details of the new law, and using business legal services to help understand the effect of the new law on your company.
More from Maria Palma
How to Reduce Teen Drunk Driving
By: Maria Palma | 11/08/2008 | Parenting
Teen drunk driving has been a growing concern for many people - especially for parents. As much as we'd like to believe that our children are innocent and will stay kids forever, the truth is, many young people are involved in illegal activities such as drinking and driving.
How to Prevent a Wrongful Dui Conviction
By: Maria Palma | 12/07/2008 | National, State, Local
If you’ve been stopped for drinking and driving, it can be an embarrassing situation. However, if you’ve had only one drink and you think that you’re ok, there’s no need to stress out. There have been cases, though, in which a person was pulled over by the police and was arrested even though they weren’t over the legal limit for drinking.
10 Tips to Quit Drinking Alcohol
By: Maria Palma | 03/04/2008 | Addictions
Alcoholism is a disease that plagues many people. To quit drinking alcohol takes a great deal of patience and this article provides tips to help you overcome this addiction.
Buying Auto Insurance After a Drunk Driving Charge
By: Maria Palma | 03/04/2008 | Insurance
Buying auto insurance after you've been charged with a DUI can seem like a daunting task. Many auto insurance companies will not cover because you've now become a greater risk and if you do find an auto insurance company that will cover you, they'll charge higher premiums.
California Dui Expungement: What are the Benefits?
By: Maria Palma | 01/04/2008 | National, State, Local
If you're arrested and charged with a DUI in the state of California, it is highly likely that the incident will go on your criminal record, or "rap sheet". However, there is the possibility that you can get a DUI charged expunged.
Drunk Driving Field and Chemical Tests in California
By: Maria Palma | 01/04/2008 | National, State, Local
If you operate a vehicle in California, police officers can and will pull a person over anytime they are suspected of driving while intoxicated. This article briefly outlines the type of field and chemical tests that are administered by officers to determine if a person has indeed been drinking and driving.
Dui Breath Analyzing Devices: are They Reliable?
By: Maria Palma | 29/03/2008 | Law
For many years now there have been arguments between DUI lawyers and law enforcement about the reliability of drunk driving analyzing devices.
What Can You Do to Reduce the Stress of a Dui Arrest?
By: Maria Palma | 21/03/2008 | Law
Have you been arrested for drunk driving (DUI) and not sure what to do next? It’s a stressful and overwhelming situation, but if you follow some of the tips outlined in this article, hopefully it will ease some of the headache and worry.
Law 
