Enrico Schaefer is the founding attorney of Traverse Legal, PLC, a law firm specializing in non-compete and non-solicitation agreements, trade secret, confidentiality matters and also in litigation regarding minority shareholder rights.
We live in a highly competitive world where highly paid executives and business persons have easy access to trade, market, and consumer information. Unlike before, these executives and other employees are highly mobile, with the ability to easily move between firms, markets,and even competitors. The problem for the companies who operate within these markets is the danger that this mobility poses to their efforts to best their competition - a danger that can often be minimized through non-compete agreements. As of late, Michigan courts and the Michigan legislature have tried to deal with the realities of our 21rst century marketplace in dealing with the enforceability of non-compete agreements, and have expanded upon the rights of companies to utilize such agreements.
In Michigan, the validity of non-compete agreements is governed by section 4a of the Michigan Antitrust Reform Act, a statute passed by the Legislature in 1987, as well as the many cases interpreting that statute. Together, the statute and the case law set forth the parameters defining those agreements that are enforceable and those that are not. The statute seeks to strike a compromise between the protection of an employer’s competitive business interests and an employee’s right to earn a living. As such, courts interpreting non-compete agreements focus their analysis in four areas:
* The agreement must protect a company’s reasonable competitive business interest. Among the factors in determining whether the agreement protects a reasonable competitive business interest are the employee’s position in the company, compensation paid to that employee and the level and amount of specific competitive information acquired during employment, which may include such areas as trade secrets or special training conferred on the employee.
* The agreement must be reasonable as to the length of time the employee is prohibited from working in the line of business. Again, each case is 'fact sepcific' and numerous factors are analyzed in determine what is a reasonable length fort non-compete contract.
* The agreement must be reasonable as to the geographic area the employer seeks to prevent the employee from working in. While the employee’s immediate area of employment would most likely be upheld as a reasonable territorial restriction, wider restrictions require a greater showing that the agreement seeks to protect the employer’s reasonable competitive business interest.
* The agreement’s restrictions on the type of employment or line of business must be reasonable. Courts will look less favorably on deliberately vague, over-reaching or “blanket” agreements.
The enforcement of con-compete contracts in Michigan courts mainly occur on a case-by-case basis, with remedies that include the issuing of restraining orders or injunctions and the awarding of monetary damages.
To businesses who may be interested in utilizing non-compete agreements, it is important to note that even if one condition of a non-compete agreement is deemed unenforceable, it does not void the remainder of the agreement - leaving the rest of the contract valid and enforceable. Businesses of all types, especially those with multi-state operations, must also understand that the rules for non-compete agreements vary from state to state. What’s enforceable in Michigan may not be in one of our neighbor states. Moreover, in order to effectively face a dispute arising from a non-compete agreement, employers should not delay in acting on known breaches of such agreements. The longer an employer delays between the discovery of unlawful competition and pursuit of a legal remedy, the weaker becomes the employer’s request for injunctive relief.
Like any contract, non-compete agreements define the expectations of each party and are subject to negotiations, depending upon the bargaining strength of the parties. Employers should have legal counsel help draft these agreements to ensure that they meet the employer’s expectations and are enforceable. Employees, on the other hand, should review such agreements carefully to ensure that they understand the restrictions on future employment should they ever leave the company.
Also, be sure to remind those leaving your company of their legal obligations during any exit interview. In this way, employers will strike a favorable, yet serious business tone, while best ensuring that any non-compete agreement can be enforced, should the need arise. In an instance in which a breach is realized, a threat letter is usually the first step to ensure the parties abide by non-compete terms and avoid litigation.
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A
- 10 Step Web Design and Development Contract Agreement
- A Nanny Contract Agreement - What Is A Standard Nanny Agreement?
- The Contract Agreement in Today's Globalized it Environment
- California Contract Lawyer On How A California Contract Attorney Determines If There Is A Breach Of Contract And What Damages Are Recoverable
- The Importance Of Signing Business Contracts
- Contract Law – Its Importance in the World Today
- Contract Law Summarised; Explanations, Definitions, Cases
- Resolving Jurisdiction With Independent Contracts




Duval County Public Records - Getting the Information You Want at Duval Pubic Records
By: Dean Gray | 14/12/2009Performing a search for Duval County public records becomes easier nowadays with the availability of online access to public documents. The results you will get shall include any or all of the following depending on stipulations made on some documents: birth certificate, marriage certificate, divorce records, and other personal information of the person.
Background Check by Social Security Number - Check Background Using SSN
By: Ray Penn | 14/12/2009Many people are now performing background check by social security number or SSN because they fully enjoy the benefits of doing this kind of investigation which is mostly done for their own safety. Compared to searching for people using their first and last names which may sometimes show numerous results on persons having the same first and last names, in this case the result that you will get is precisely the person who owns the SSN.
Do the Police still need high powered small handguns?
By: Paul Ingersole | 14/12/2009Almost all police officers are required to provide their own gun for use on duty. Remington brand models are often the most widely used. This is because of their proven quality, relatively low cost, and generous policies regarding repairs and returns. A crucial piece of police academy training involves being properly trained on how firearms work, safety regulations, proper cleaning of firearms, and when it is necessary to draw your firearm.
The Basic Elements of a Vanity Makeup Table
By: Tarris Bradley | 12/12/2009You might think that getting ready for the day in your bathroom is fine. But what if you could sit down in the plush comfort of your master bedroom and put your makeup on and do your hair? Once you try it, you might never go back to getting ready in your bathroom every day! A vanity makeup table is the perfect way to bring on the morning in the comfort of your bedroom and away from the morning hustle and bustle in your household.
Solution of Indo pak relations
By: Dalip Wasan. | 12/12/2009India and pakistan shall continue fighting till kashmir problem is there and therefore, the only solution is this line of control be converted into international line and if they do not agree some other country may come and pass orders for both the dountries.
Solution of Indo pak relations
By: Dalip Wasan. | 12/12/2009India and pakistan shall continue fighting till kashmir problem is there and therefore, the only solution is this line of control be converted into international line and if they do not agree some other country may come and pass orders for both the dountries.
Let A Corporate Bankruptcy Lawyer Shoulder All Responsibilities
By: Douglas M. Parks | 12/12/2009At the time when a company files for corporate bankruptcy a number of questions arise that need to be answered satisfactorily and which often is best answered by a corporate bankruptcy lawyer. Investors for one will be curious to know what is going on with the company and will also want to know who is going to take care of their interests and most importantly will need answers to how much value remains in the securities of the company.
Shares with us vital things to remember to avoid getting traffic tickets on the road
By: Steve Miller | 11/12/2009They say that if you wanted to avoid getting hurt or jeopardized, prevention is still the best and ultimate policy to observe. This principle is not just applicable to emotional problems but it is also pertinent on the rules of the law, especially on traffic rules and regulations. If you wanted to avoid getting pulled over by an officer and paying costly traffic tickets, avoidance is still the best policy you can always apply. When we say apply the word “avoidance” it doesn’t confine being a goo
The Acpa: Trademark Violations in Domains
By: Enrico Schaefer | 17/05/2007 | Intellectual PropertyDefendants are often confused by lawsuits that come from trademark holders who are seeking to have domains that correspond to their trademarks transferred to themselves. This confusion arises from the fact that registrars do little to nothing to validate the legal right of a registrant to a domain during registration. On the other side, the ACPA protects the rights of many trademark holders when it comes to the use of that trademark in top-level domains.
Domain Name Dispute Resolution: Choosing your Forum
By: Enrico Schaefer | 15/05/2007 | Internet LawWhereas a civil or ciminal case must be arbitrated in a specified court, domain name dispute cases are resolved through service providers such as WIPO and NAF, providers which serve the same purpose but should not be selected at random.
Udrp Panels: What you Should Know
By: Enrico Schaefer | 10/05/2007 | Intellectual PropertyJust as a trial attorney never enters a courtroom without researching his judge, those who arbitrate before a UDRP Panel need to be aware of the views of the panelists, and the rights granted in the UDRP that can be used to shield hostile panelists.
Preventing Domain Name Theft: Beyond the Udrp
By: Enrico Schaefer | 07/05/2007 | Domain NamesWhile the UDRP is an efficient method for achieving the transfer of domain names that violate trademarks, it has no method for preventing their violation in the first place. Luckily, with some help and active prevention, it is possible to prevent any run-ins with the UDRP.
Pornosquatting: a Domain Name Theft Nightmare
By: Enrico Schaefer | 07/05/2007 | Domain NamesWhen facing a stolen domain name, or having intended visitors sent over to sites filled with obscene material rather than your own, it is often the most important time to get legal advice and fight to have your trademark restored.
Non-compete Contracts as a Tool for Protecting Competitive Edge
By: Enrico Schaefer | 03/05/2007 | National, State, LocalTodays economy is filled with industries who face unprecedented competition as they struggle to gain an edge upon their competitors. As never before, non-compete and non-solicitation agreements are becoming effective avenues through which businesses can protect investments and information that help them in the competitive market.
Non-compete Contracts: the Employer Perspective
By: Enrico Schaefer | 02/05/2007 | Strategic PlanningNon-compete and non-solicitation contracts, along with the legal basis upon which they rest, are complex issues that face both employees and their employers and should be totally understood in order to ensure the rights of both parties are protected in the case of a dispute.
The Michigan Sales Represetatives Commission Act: Protecting yourself
By: Enrico Schaefer | 30/04/2007 | National, State, LocalWith the Michigan Supreme Court yet to make a decision following the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals one, the specifics of the enforcement of the SRCA has grown more unclear. However, there are things that a producer can do before they face the severe penalties for what the SRCA deems "improper" withholding of sales representative commissions.