Sometimes I feel sorry for the local weatherman. He or she has to get in front of the television camera every day and give forecasts up to a week in advance knowing full well that those forecasts are apt to be wrong. Here's why.
Weather forecasting is based on computer modeling and these computer models are based on two things; the physics and the data. Each model that the forecaster can choose from is based on different physics assumptions, sometimes very different.
For example, will a storm just entering the west coast of the United States travel across the continent without any intensification and exit the east coast three days later? Or, will it slowly intensify as the days go on and exit the east coast as a major noreaster? Each computer model handles the situation differently and the forecaster must choose which one to use.
Quite often the atmosphere is in a state which is a combination of several different physical models, not just one. In this case, it is not at all unusual for the computer models to predict wildly differing forecasts for three to seven days into the future. When this happens, the best the forecaster can do is to put all the options out on the table. Of course, this is not what the public wants to hear and a single forecast must be made. When the inevitable happens and the forecast is wrong the weatherman must indeed have a thick skin if he is to withstand the barrage of jokes and insults which will surely come his way.
As if that is not enough, here is the real problem. These forecasting models are based, of course, on the data that is input into the computer program. This data is a compilation of current weather observations and this data is VERY incomplete. As an example, suppose two observations are fifty miles apart. The observers diligently compile the relevant weather statistics and send them off to the national weather service where the data is then input into each computer model.
Here is the problem. In the fifty miles seperating the observers, there might be some weather phenomena that is going, through no fault of anyone, unreported. This may be something very small but as the program extrapolates out days and weeks ahead, that little something may, and usually does, have a huge effect on the weather that will be seen in the forecast area.
It is known as the "butterfly effect"( a butterfly flapping his wings halfway aroung the world will eventually have an effect on the weather seen locally), and it is the dirty little secret of weather forecasting. Until we are able to collect data in a close to continuous fashion between observation points there is very little chance that our weather forecast a week ahead will be correct and nobody sees this possibility occuring in the near future.
So the next time you see or hear your local weather forecaster speaking confidently about next week's forecast, know that deep inside he or she is grimacing and taking that forecast with a whole bushel full of salt. And please, hold all those weather jokes!
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Scale of 1 to 10 definition.
By: Charles | 20-07-2008
When the comfort index is expressed as a number between 1 and 10, what is the good and bad end of this scale? Is one good or bad?
Pondering existance of sap
By: charlotte | 20-07-2008
I have a deck that is about 5 years old. This is the first time I have put a stain on it. The deck was cleaned with a preasure washer .I used an olympic solid stain. after several days i noticed that a sap like substance was beading on several boards. Any idea what has caused this and how i can clean this sap off the boards? Thank you C.J Griffing@nc.rr.com
I'm Hot
By: leored | 19-07-2008
why did yall make it so hot out here today? LOL
What will weather be on july 23 thru 26 in Smogen ...
By: Lou | 19-07-2008
what will weather be on july 23 thru 26 in Smogen, Sweden? Thanks, Lou Spitz...
Can you tell me how much snow, if any, fell on ...
By: Cdechon | 18-07-2008
Can you tell me how much snow, if any, fell on Friday, February 22, 2008
in Lodi, New Jersey 07644
pat9730@aol.com Charles Dechon
What will the weather be like in destin fla on ...
By: me | 17-07-2008
what will the weather be like in destin fla on july 26-aug 2 2008?
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Nature Articles
Unilever Planning On Certifying All Its Palm Oil
By: Scott Miscall | 19/07/2008
It might be a lofty aim but Unilever has very serious intentions of implementing it. By 2015 Unilever plans on all its palm oil sources certified.
Exploring The Underwater World In Thailand
By: Daniel Wallace | 17/07/2008
Thailand offers some of the finest diving spots in the world. The warm, tropical waters of Thailand mean diving gives you a fantastic opportunity to see the beauty from below the waves.
Save Trees - Use Paper: The Facts
By: Patrick Omari | 14/07/2008
Keep hearing that you're killing the rainforest when you throw away paper? Worried about all the homeless monkeys caused by your notebook? Don't be, this article tells you why
Austin Natural Pools: Hamilton Pool Preserve
By: Ki Gray | 14/07/2008
Austin has a number of different parks and natural pools. This article talks about Hamilton Pool.
The Original Green Material
By: Paul Jamerson | 14/07/2008
How to be green and self-sufficient by keeping Honey Bees. In this day and age when the government, industry and environmentalists are calling for green products - they seem to forget there was a time when all products were Green. That time was not that long ago. If you are 59 years old (as I am) or have access to grandparents or Great-grandparents ask them what they did to live.
Outdoor Fun In Austin, Texas
By: Ki Gray | 12/07/2008
Regardless of your interests, Austin, Texas, offers a wide range of outdoor activities to keep you busy year-round.
What if a Man Woke Up a Woman and What if a Woman Woke Up a Man? What Would You Do?
By: nadia cherubin | 11/07/2008
Is this particular topic mother nature? or is it just something in someone else's imagination that would make them think that would really happen?
My Life as a Festival Singer in Africa
By: Flor Ayag | 09/07/2008
We would collect up to $75 for a public performance—a large sum of money among our people, even more than some families’ income for two or three months. Our singing and dancing group was in great demand at festivals held throughout the towns and villages of our chiefdom, as well as in nearby countries in West Africa.
News and Society 
