(November 10, 2007) The turmoil in Pakistan presents somewhat of a philosophical dilemma: Is allowing a political party that espouses non-democratic rule to run in an election democracy?
The tumult over Musharraf's declaration of emergency rule overshadows a far more serious issue. His political opposition is an ever-growing militant Islamic party, sympathetic to the Taliban and al Qaeda. Is giving this party a chance to take power really democracy?
Somewhat enigmatic is Condoleezza Rice's statement, prompting Musharraf to cancel emergency rule and allow elections to proceed: "The U.S. has made clear it does not support extra-constitutional measures, because those measures take Pakistan away from the path of democracy and civilian rule." If the opposition wins, will that put Pakistan on a "path of democracy and civilian rule?" Highly doubtful. So at what point should we start worrying about a militant Islamic state with nuclear weapons: when they win the election, when they have their inaugural ball, or when the missiles start flying?
We seem to hold other countries to rules of "democracy" that we do not accept in our political system. The privilege of holding public office has been denied in this country countless of times for reasons far less egregious than having connections to terrorism.
In 2001, the nomination of Linda Chavez as Labor Secretary was withdrawn when it was revealed she paid an illegal immigrant to do housework. In 1993, the candidacies for Attorney General, Zoe Baird and Judge Kimba M. Wood, were withdrawn because of their hiring practices of nannies. The nomination of Bernard Kerik as Secretary of Homeland Security was withdrawn in 2004 because of a shady background. Richard Nixon, who was democratically elected as President in 1972, was brought down because of shady practices.
Obviously, the mere fact that one goes through a democratic process to get into office, does not necessarily make that nomination or appointment legal or acceptable. There are a plethora of legal precedents and justifications in a democracy to keep militants out of office, even by force, if necessary. (If someone deemed unqualified for the Presidency decided to move into the White House, would we not remove him by force, regardless of how many votes he got?)
The line Musharraf may have crossed is arresting lawyers, human rights activists and the like, who are not connected with his opposition. But we must differentiate between these individuals and terrorist-sympathizers. To allow militants to run for election would be a repeat of the Gaza debacle -- an experiment in "democratic elections" that failed miserably. With a nuclear power, we can't afford the same disaster.
To call militants running in an election a democratic process, is a myopic, self-defeating interpretation of democracy, and contrary to the spirit of the Declaration of Independence: " ... all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness ... whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government..."
It speaks of a government, obviously already in office, that has become destructive. What does this say about a party that is not yet in office and is already destructive enough that it has no qualms about massacring people in cold blood? Can giving such a party a chance to bring its destructiveness into government be called democracy? That's ludicrous. Contrary to what the politically correct pundits would like us to believe about equality, barring militants, terrorists and terrorist-sympathizers from running for office -- is democracy!
by Josh Greenberger
This has been an excerpt from his free book on evolution at EvolutionDead.com
- Related Videos
- Related Articles
- Ask / Related Q&A




Mexican Marine Families revenge slaying shocks the world and 4 members of the feared Leyva drug cartel arrested
By: michael Webster | 30/12/2009The military precision type pre-dawn attack came just hours after the navy honored Mexican Marine Melquisedet Angulo as a national hero at a memorial service for his part in the successful attack on the powerful Arturo Beltran Leyva family which killed the leader.
Staying Up to Date with Google Alerts
By: Hannah Miller | 29/12/2009Google.com, the number one most visited website and largest search engine, is the number one resource for all your need to know (and want to know) fast facts. Google Alerts, a service of Google, brings the news and information to your Inbox! Read more to find out how Google Alerts work and how they can help you!
Nigeria will suffer if Yar'Adua dies in office, says David-West
By: Olukunle Odebo | 29/12/2009Should the president resign based on the state of his health
Iran clamps down on opposition leaders after protests
By: Olukunle Odebo | 29/12/2009About 300 people were detained after the protests, police said on Sunday. They included members of the banned opposition group, Mujahideen Khalq Organisation (MKO) or the People's Mujahideen, Press TV reported.
Israel plans to build more homes in east Jerusalem
By: Olukunle Odebo | 29/12/2009ISRAEL has announced plans for nearly 700 homes in mainly Arab East Jerusalem, despite Palestinian and international demands that it freeze building there.
Bhalessa- An experience of Peacemaking
By: Sadaket Malik | 29/12/2009The towering town of Bhalessa, thickly carpeted with evergreen forests and dotted with tiny hamlets, is home to roughly equal numbers of Hindus and Muslims, Besides walls of suspicion strong ties bind other Hindus and Muslims and have halted the complete polarisation of the populace. This is something that I've been attempting to study since long. A township well knitted by historical kalgoni temple and Markazi Jamia Masjid managed by Sanathan Dharam Sabha and Temari Committee.
How to Prevent Basement Flooding
By: Ashley Ford | 29/12/2009It is far better to try and be one step ahead of a potential basement flood than one step behind. Typically it is very simple and easy for you to ensure that your home, basement and foundation are protected from potential flooding. Able Restoration has taken the time to help you out by providing you with a few helpful and simple steps that you should take to help protect your homes basement.
Keep your Investigation Confidential and Explore hidden facts
By: Sleuth India | 29/12/2009Crime situation have worsen with time. For individuals as well as corporates this rising level of crimes leads to investigate and keep your eye open and explore the hidden elements which might try to negatively influence.
The Aimless Presidency of Barack Obama
By: Josh Greenberger | 26/07/2009 | PoliticsBarack Obama's utter failure to accomplish a damn thing in office besides drive our country into deeper crisis is, I believe, not an organized plan of any sort. It's something more fundamental than that. This is a man drunk with power and his own perceived glory.
The Barack Obama Con Job Continues
By: Josh Greenberger | 22/07/2009 | PoliticsSupporters of Barack Obama's current national healthcare initiative are being taken in by a new self-serving con. "Health care for everyone" is health care for no one.
Top 10 Signs Your Life Is Too Similar To David Letterman's
By: Josh Greenberger | 14/06/2009 | HumorSummary: Top 10 Signs Your Life Is Too Similar To David Letterman's
The Myth That Speciation Is Evolution
By: Josh Greenberger | 12/06/2009 | ScienceYou often hear evolutionists point to speciation as evidence of evolution. This couldn't be farther from the truth.
The Fossil Ida Is An Assault On A Gullible Public
By: Josh Greenberger | 20/05/2009 | ScienceOne fossil does not represent a transitional species any more than the remains of a two-headed snake represents a transition of snakes from one head to two heads.
Tiktaalik: Scientists' Insult to the Public's Intelligence
By: Josh Greenberger | 22/01/2009 | ScienceDo scientists' interpretations of evolutionary data represent a case of following preconceived notions, while neglecting other more logical explanations that are actually supported by independent empirical evidence?
Introduction to Affiliate Program Income
By: Josh Greenberger | 14/12/2008 | EntrepreneurshipStarting a business is usually an expensive proposition. But with an online "affiliate program" you can at least eliminate most of the setup expenses.
What's Happening to our Once-robust Economy?
By: Josh Greenberger | 30/11/2008 | PoliticsWe've tried every trick in the book to fix our economy -- reducing interest rates, bailouts, stimulus packages, etc. -- but nothing's helped. Why is this so hard to fix?