Apparently sport is not the right arena in which to express concern for human rights according to the French national Olympic committee (CNOSF). Its president, Henri Sérandour, has banned this country's athletes from wearing a badge with the slogan "Pour un monde meilleur" (For a better world) during this summer's games in Beijing.
Sérandour, told L'Equipe television that such a move would contravene the Olympic charter, which he said, "Precluded any tangible demonstration of any kind during (Olympic) competition and the opening and closing ceremonies."
It's a sad reversal of a statement made by the same man just a couple of weeks ago after French athletes decided to adopt the badge, which depicts the slogan above the five Olympic rings.
Back then Sérandour said he would fight for the sentiment for a "better world" not only within the International Olympic Committee (IOC) but also "as a message for the 2008 games and beyond."
But he now seems to have caved in to pressure and changed his opinion to fall in line with that of the IOC, which has assured Chinese authorities that although athletes are free to express their personal views in public, they won't be allowed to under the aegis of the games.
While Sérandour's decision might be binding on French athletes, it's far from receiving universal support from others who have spoken out about the need to separate sport from politics.
France's junior sports minister, and former national rugby coach, Bernard Laporte, called the move regrettable and said he didn't find the badge at all aggressive in its declaration.
"It doesn't attack China and on the contrary it borrows from the declared objectives of the IOC itself,' he said in a radio interview.
The badge was a compromise as originally the organisation representing France's Olympic athletes had proposed wearing a green ribbon in support of human rights. But that was considered too overtly "political" by the CNOSF and scrapped.
Some might see an interesting difference of priorities at play here. The preamble to the United Nations charter guarantees the right to freedom of expression, as does European and French law.
But a private money-making organisation such as the IOC has a different set of rules and principles, in which the logos of sports equipment manufacturers who help finance the games clearly carry more weight than an expression of support for human rights even in the mildest of forms.
So on the one hand while the Chinese will be allowed to pursue a largely propaganda-inspired ceremony having greatly ignored international wishes for reopening a dialogue with Tibet's exiled spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, and improving their human rights records, freedom of expression won't be extended to individual athletes.
Sérandour's decision means that French athletes will in effect be forced to toe the IOC line that rejects political, religious or racial propaganda.
France's part, and in particular that of its sportsmen and women, in this whole masquerade is probably far from over even if the country's political leaders have been more than diffident in deciding whether to attend the opening ceremony.
Let's just hope that the gagging of athletes doesn't extend to any French gold medal winners who choose to belt out the national anthem, which includes a line to rise against tyranny.
Related Articles
Olympic Boycott Squabble Escalates
By: Johnny Summerton | 16/04/2008 | News and Society
French business faces threat in China as campaign is launched to boycott supermarket chain, Carrefour.
Sportsister Meets Kelly Holmes
By: Louise Hudson | 03/07/2008 | Track and Field
Kelly Holmes is one of the country’s best known and well liked sportswomen, thanks in part to her double gold win at the 2004 Athens Olympics. Sportsister.com chats to her about the upcoming Beijing games, getting more girls involved in sport and those gold medals.
Mobile Olympics
By: John Gray | 14/08/2008 | Cell Phones
Free news service for Vodafone customers. Stay up to date, on the Olympics, on the go
A Day in the Life of Jessica Ennis – British Heptathlete
By: Louise Hudson | 15/07/2008 | Track and Field
Sportsister.com chats to British heptathlete Jessica Ennis about her usual training plan.
Summer Olympics 2008 cities
By: Ken Cheong | 20/09/2005 | Sports and Fitness
Two cities that will host
the Olympics in China are Beijing, which is the nations capital
and Qingdao, a seaside city in the province of Shandong, in
north-east China. Let's.
Top 8 Must Do Before you Go to China
By: Justyna Rakowska | 23/10/2007 | Travel Tips
The article provides you with the basic informations about what you have to do before your trip to China, like visa application, getting tickets and vaccinations.
Olympic War of Words Heats Up
By: Johnny Summerton | 20/04/2008 | Politics
The French supermarket giant, Carrefour, once again found itself at the centre of anti-West protests as demonstrations took place in towns and cities across China at the weekend.
But the chain wasn’t the only specifically French target. There were also rallies outside the country’s embassy in Beijing and the French Lycée.
A History Of The Modern Olympics 1960 - 1988
By: Harwood E Woodpecker | 20/03/2008 | Sports and Fitness
This August (8th-24th) sees Beijing, China, hosting the games of the X X I X Olympiad. Below is listed a potted history of the Olympic games from 1960 to date including a few interesting facts about each games.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Q&A Powered by:
More from Johnny Summerton
How Could Parents Forget?
By: Johnny Summerton | 16/08/2008 | News and Society
It's a question that has preoccupied many here in France over the past month, and sadly made the headlines far too often. It's also one to which it's difficult to provide an answer.
Over the past four weeks there have been three separate incidents of young children or babies - being...
Sarkozy Set For a Constitutional Showdown
By: Johnny Summerton | 02/08/2008 | News and Society
Hardly the sexiest headline by any stretch of the imagination. But there again when it comes to institutional reform and changes to the constitution, the subject matter is hardly guaranteed to instill much enthusiasm.
The French president, Nicolas Sarkozy is fighting constitutional reform on two fronts. There is of course the...
Adieu PPDA
By: Johnny Summerton | 24/07/2008 | News and Society
There was an end of a television era here yesterday as Patrick Poivre d'Arvor, affectionately known in this country as PPDA, made his final broadcast as anchorman on TF1's prime time news slot.
Think of a news anchor in your own country, someone who has been around for donkeys years and...
Sarkozy's Union-bashing Barb
By: Johnny Summerton | 07/07/2008 | Politics
French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, does a bit of union bashing in front to his party faithful.
Ingrid Betancourt - a Heroine's Homecoming
By: Johnny Summerton | 07/07/2008 | Politics
Freed hostage, Ingrid Betancourt, expected to land to heroine's welcome in France.
Twice an Orphan - Barmy Bureaucracy or Welfare of the Child? You Judge.
By: Johnny Summerton | 05/07/2008 | News and Society
Last weekend here in France an 11-year-old boy, Joris, found himself effectively orphaned for the second time. He was taken into care after his father, 34-year-old Aboubakar Coulibaly, was deported back to his native Côte d'Ivoire.
Coulibaly had been granted sole custody of Joris back in March 2006 after the child's...
Public Prosecutor Recommends Dropping (Jean) Sarkozy Charges
By: Johnny Summerton | 03/07/2008 | News and Society
The mysterious if somewhat exhausting case of the hit-and-run scooter and the role of the French president's son, Jean Sarkozy, could be nearing its conclusion.
A Paris prosecutor has recommended dropping charges against him, but a final decision won't be handed down until September.
The incident dates back to October 2005, when...
One Woman's French Foly
By: Johnny Summerton | 30/06/2008 | Theater
French singer, Liane Foly, wows the audiences with a host of guest appearances at the opening run of her one-woman show.
News and Society 
