David Singer is an Australian lawyer and conveyor of Jordan is Palestine International, an organisation calling for sovereignty of the West Bank and Gaza to be allocated between Israel and Jordan as the two successor states to the Mandate for Palestine.
Jordan's King Abdullah is a desperate man judging by his historic speech to the United States Congress on 7 March 2007 - and with good reason.
The Road Map - designed to create a second Arab state in former Palestine, in addition to Jordan -has unfolded in total disarray.
The Road Map had begun as a vision of President George Bush on 24 June 2002. It was an answer to, and a rejection of, the Arab Peace Initiative endorsed by the Arab League in Beirut just three months earlier.
The detailed provisions of the Road Map were finally endorsed and launched in a blaze of publicity in April 2003 by the strongest negotiating team ever assembled in world history -America, Russia, the European Union and the United Nations - affectionately dubbed the Quartet.
The Quartet's newly created State was to be born by 2005. But as of today, it is still only a twinkle in the eyes of its' sponsors and any prospects of conception, let alone its' birth, passed long ago.
On the face of it the Road Map was a sure fire winner. However its' failure to predict intransigent Arab negotiating positions was to prove its' downfall.
Only 6000 square kilometres of land known as the West Bank and Gaza was involved - an area about the size of Tokyo or Chicago.
Israel had already agreed to forego its' claims to at least 4000 square kilometres and possibly even more - depending on whose version you accept - in negotiations at Camp David presided over by President Clinton in 2000.
Surely all that was needed was a push and a shove, a tweak here and a tweak there, to divide the remaining 2000 square kilometres between the disputants thus ending what the Quartet seriously claimed to be the most intractable problem facing the world.
This has not occurred for two reasons - the Arabs wanted it all and they demanded that the 400000 Jews living there be thrown out.
Now King Abdullah has appeared before the US Congress to promote the Arab Peace Initiative as the way forward out of the Quartet's dilemma. But this Initiative demands precisely these very same unacceptable outcomes.
One must feel sorry for the predicament of King Abdullah being caught up as the unwilling filling in the Road Map - Arab Peace Initiative sandwich.
Arab unity demands he stand by the Arab Initiative and be seen to be one of its' major sponsors as the Arab world tries to rally international support for this totally flawed and outdated plan.
History and his heart should tell him something else - he needs to give the hapless Quartet the opportunity to re-route its' Road Map by announcing his readiness to negotiate the division of sovereignty of the West Bank between Jordan and Israel.
The reasons for this are compelling:
(i) Jordan was the last sovereign Arab occupier of the West Bank from 1948 -1967 during which time its' Arab residents were Jordanian citizens and subject to Jordanian law.
(ii) Such negotiations would conclude the division of the land contained in the Mandate for Palestine between the two successor States to the Mandate - Jordan and Israel.
(iii) The negotiations would take place within the parameters of the existing peace treaty signed by Israel and Jordan in 1994, where "deal breakers" such as refugees, Jerusalem and water have already been identified and solutions prescribed.
(iv) The negotiations could be concluded within a relatively short period of time based on the general principle that the heavily populated Arab areas would become part of Jordan whilst the heavily populated Jewish areas would become part of Israel
(v) No Arabs or Jews would be forced to leave their present homes. Where Jews or Arabs found themselves on the wrong side of the new border, they could be given the option of staying as citizens or being compensated if they wanted to move.
Jordan clearly does not have the strength to announce and enter into these negotiations of its own volition.
It needs the political, financial, and military support of the Quartet and the endorsement of the Arab League.
King Abdullah's plea to the Congress for "America's leadership in a peace process that delivers results not next year, not in five years, but this year" must be understood in the light of the choices now facing the Quartet, Jordan and the Arab League.
Following the Road Map in the direction of the Arab Peace Initiative can only lead to a dead end and guarantee many more years of death and suffering for the Jewish and Arab inhabitants in the region.
Dividing the West Bank between Jordan and Israel can open a new page in the Road Map that will answer His Majesty's emotional plea before the Congress for all people in the region to be allowed to live in peace and harmony.
Let us hope that the ingredients for the new peace sandwich will include lashings of encouragement and support by the Quartet and the Arab League for Jordan's central role in resolving the conflict.
If it doesn't, who will eat the stale sandwiches and who will be left to pick up the crumbs?
- Related Articles
- Related Q&A
- Quartet Crumbles, Arab League Rumbles, Israel Fumbles
- Bush and Abdullah Chew Over the Bones of Palestine
- President Bush Presses the Palestine Panic Button
- Palestine - Bye Bye Bush, Onwards Obama
- Jordan's King Abdullah - the Ham in the Sandwich
- Palestinians Must Change Mindset
- Palestine - United Nations Security Council Flirts With Racist Fantasyland
- Palestine, Fantasy and Tales From the Arabian Nights




All Hail Janet Napolitano Secretary Of Homeland Security
By: Nui Kahuna | 01/01/2010There are those who will say that it isn’t poor little Janet’s fault that she can’t find her ample ass with four sets of eyes and three pair of hands. She has the damnable itch that just won’t go away, the itch being those quirky jihadists that are seemingly immune to every powder, cream, and lotion the Obama administration wants to use in order to make everything soothingly calm.
Bhalessa exposes tall claims of successive governments
By: Sadaket Malik | 31/12/2009India is striving to achieve the slogans like of “Health for All Food and Water for All, the government has had claimed progress and achievement of such programmes in rural areas, but when one go deep in the rural areas, the picture exposes the claims of the authorities as there are thousands of areas without health facilities, food, water and basic amenities.
Bhalessa unsung politicians' kashmir Policy
By: Sadaket Malik | 31/12/2009The history of the state lacks absurdly the evidence of viewpoints made by majority of unsung heroes of the state on the trouble torn Kashmir. Their Kashmir policy, handling the situation of communal disharmony over time, the pages of history are absurdly lacking the mention of such epitomes of peace who played acted as a catalyst for the cementing Hindu Muslim amity during a course of time.
Niaz put Bhalessa on drivers' seat: A historical Analysis
By: Sadaket Malik | 31/12/2009Gone are the days when area like of Bhalessa witnessed a tumultuous days. Of late, there was a paucity of community leadership on the one hand and sacracity of a membership in assembly to represent the improvised terrain of Bhalessa on the other.
Bhalessa: A saparate political identity imperative
By: Sadaket Malik | 31/12/2009Of late, the people in governance are in favor of creation of separate constituency under the pretext of wazir Commission report. Administrative reforms are already in place. The recent changes seemed to be happened.
Get Latest Steering News of India in One Simple Click
By: NancyDante | 31/12/2009Zopag.com is leading Live Breaking News web portal includes Live Breaking News from India, World, Entertainment, and Lifestyle for 24x7. Exclusive Breaking News of India, Latest Breaking News in India.
Obama Wasn't Kidding About Being The Education President
By: sanajai | 31/12/2009If President Obama has his way, next summer’s public school vacation may be sharply reduced. The president believes that American kids spend too little time in school, and this puts them at a disadvantage with other students around the globe.
Facts about the Vietnam War
By: Samus Bendwan | 31/12/2009The Vietnam war was a milestone moment in world history. Much of the Earth today is shaped by the events from this crucial war.
Palestine - Perpetual Pantomime Pursues Peace
By: david singer | 22/02/2009 | PoliticsBenjamin Netanyahu's invitation to try and form Israel's next Government will see a cast of new faces - and some old ones - taking lead roles in the world's longest running pantomime trying to solve one of the world's longest running problems - what to do with the 6% of Palestine that belongs to no one.
Palestine - the Lieberman Factor
By: david singer | 13/02/2009 | PoliticsIsrael's biggest winner in the recent elections - Avigdor Lieberman - is not the ogre the media make him out to be.
Palestine - Obama Quicksteps Into the Quicksand
By: david singer | 06/02/2009 | PoliticsPresident Obama is treading on dangerous ground in appearing to believe the two state option is still a possibility.
Palestine - George Mitchell Munches on Middle East Lunches
By: david singer | 01/02/2009 | PoliticsPresident Obama's Middle East envoy - George Mitchell - has set off on his first trip to the Middle East under his new boss. What the boss had to say will need to be listened to very carefully by those with whom Mr Mitchell lunches.
Gaza - Cranky Ban Ki Engages in Hanky-panky
By: david singer | 23/01/2009 | PoliticsUN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon seems intent on rebuilding Gaza and rehabilitating its citizens when the likelihood is that it will all be destroyed again whilst Hamas remains in occupation and political control. Giving the population the right to seek safe haven either permanently or temporarily in other countries until the political situation in Gaza is stabilised would seem a much wiser option to pursue.
Palestine - Bye Bye Bush, Onwards Obama
By: david singer | 19/01/2009 | PoliticsPresident-elect Obama should learn from the failures of past Presidents to end the 130 years old Arab-Jewish conflict over Palestine and realize the best he can do at the present time and in the current circumstances is attempt to effectively manage - not resolve -the conflict.
Egypt and Jordan - Lifelines to Gaza and West Bank
By: david singer | 14/01/2009 | PoliticsJohn Bolton, former US Ambassador to the United Nations and leading international analyst Daniel Pipes have both proposed independently of each other and within the space of a few days that Egypt re-enter Gaza and Jordan re-enter the West Bank to resume the roles they played in those regions between 1948-1967. This option to the failed Roadmap process is now starting to take root and could be the policy approach that President-elect Barack Obama could do well to fully consider.
Gaza - Oust Hamas or Surrender to Terror
By: david singer | 05/01/2009 | PoliticsHamas must be removed from Gaza if there is to be any hope of reconciliation between Jews and Arabs.Anything less will be surrendering to terror.