Estimating by Percentages

Author: Tim Bryce

| Posted: 06-03-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 44 | Rating: (64)

(?)

"Remember, it's Ready, Aim, Fire; any other sequence is counterproductive."
- Bryce's Law

Having been involved with the systems methodologies field for over 30 years I have been occasionally asked what percentage of time in a project should typically be devoted to a specific phase of work, for example a Phase 1 Feasibility Study, Phase 2 Systems Design, etc. Basically, the reason the person wants to know this is to use it as a means for estimating the remainder of the project. For example, if I were to say Phase 1 represents 10% of the overall project, they would simply multiply the amount of time spent in Phase 1 by ten. This is an unreliable approach for estimating which is why I usually balk at giving out such figures.

Systems development projects vary in size from large to small and although statistics should certainly be maintained, I still consider this an erroneous approach to estimating. Instead, I recommend basing an estimate on a rough design of the product to be built (the system), including all of its pieces and parts, such as inputs, outputs, files, records, data elements, etc. Some of these components may be reused from other systems, some may require modification, and some may be entirely new. This is called estimating based on the system's "Bill of Materials," a simple concept derived from engineering and manufacturing. Even if a project only involves a single program (as opposed to a major system), I would still examine the types and number of components affected by the assignment.

Having said all of this, let me give you my spin on the proportion of work in the typical systems development project. I have seen many companies skip through the early phases in order to get to the programming phases which is considered the important work. Under this scenario, programming represents 85% of the project. Instead I advocate more time spent in the early phases for better clarity of requirements definition and for producing better specifications for the programmers and DBA's to follow. Under this scenario, I see as much as 60% in the early phases involving systems analysis and design, 15% in programming, and 25% in implementation and review. You heard right, 15% in programming. Why the disparity? Simply because programmers have long suffered from the lack of decent specifications and end up spinning their wheels over and over again trying to deliver what is needed. But if you concentrate on better specifications upfront, the guesswork is eliminated for the programmer.

Some people consider the upfront work to be somewhat frivolous, that the "real work" is down in programming. I don't know why this is, perhaps programming is more tangible since screens and reports can be visibly shown to people. But I do not subscribe to this notion, and believe the vital work to be in the early phases, but then again, I am considered a dinosaur by the "Agile" methodology people. Regardless, if you have to build anything of substance, be it a bridge, a skyscraper, an automobile, or a system or a single program, you have to do your homework first, otherwise you find yourself constantly tearing things down and rebuilding them over and over again. If we built bridges the same way we build systems in this country, this would be a nation run by ferryboats.

One last word on applying percentages to project estimates, the danger here is that you might calculate you are 90% complete; inevitably you will discover the last 10% will take forever. So, my recommendation is to avoid the percentage trap and consider the Bill of Materials you are going to work on instead.

If you would like to discuss this with me in more depth, please do not hesitate to send me an e-mail.

Rate this Article:

Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).

Article Tags: Tim, Bryce, Mba, Florida, Management, Irm, Project, Estimating, Percentages

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/project-management-articles/estimating-by-percentages-352381.html

Print article

Send to friend

Publish this Article

Author feedback

About the Author:

Tim Bryce is a writer and management consultant located in Palm Harbor, Florida.
http://www.phmainstreet.com/timbryce.htm

He can be contacted at: timb001@phmainstreet.com

Copyright © 2008 Tim Bryce. All rights reserved.

Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means to drive traffic to your website and promote yourself and your business. Join us today - It's Free!

Article Comments

Add new Comment

Understanding Effectiveness
By: Tim Bryce | 01/04/2008 | Management
Discusses the use of worker time and how it impacts estimating and scheduling in Project Management.

Project Management Requires a Road Map
By: Tim Bryce | 11/01/2008 | Project Management
Discusses the differences between methodologies and Project Management.

Screamers
By: Tim Bryce | 24/08/2007 | Home & Family
Discusses children in public places.

Recording your Time
By: Tim Bryce | 08/02/2008 | Management
Discusses why people resist keeping track of their time.

The Mini-project Manager Concept
By: Tim Bryce | 31/08/2006 | Project Management
Unlike Theory X, the MPM concept seeks to empower workers and make them more responsible for their actions. It promotes more management and less supervision. Actually, under the MPM concept, the individual is expected to act professionally and supervise themselves.

Apathy & Bonus - Today's Writing Habits
By: Tim Bryce | 31/08/2007 | Business
Here I describe how apathy affects us and how we are being conditioned to be so. Also, I have a Bonus section on "Today's Writing Habits."

The Adverse Effects of Technology
By: Tim Bryce | 05/07/2007 | Information Technology
Discusses the effects of technology on our socialization skills.

Doctors' Offices
By: Tim Bryce | 13/07/2007 | Health
Describes why patients want to stay away from them.

Got a Question? Ask.

Ask the community a question about this article:

Frequently Asked Questions

I am trying to find out about 5 family members ...
By: SUN | 06-10-2008
I am trying to find out about 5 family members (not related to me) that died on Feb. 28, 1971 and are buried in the Indian Trail North Carolina cemetary. I would like to know what happened, what caused their deaths. The local newspare archives only go back to 1989 on line. I would like to know the best way to get this information without driving all over. I have partial names and some birth dates.

What phase includes determining what you would do ...
By: scott | 04-10-2008
what phase includes determining what you would do inthe event a disaster should occur?

I had done diploma in computer scienceafter 10th ...
By: anup | 30-09-2008
i had done diploma in computer scienceafter 10th , i have 1 yr experince ,can i go for MCA

Waiting period?
By: verbalkint | 28-09-2008
How long does it take to get the money once you turn in a winning lottery ticket?

Fund management industry
By: Naw | 25-09-2008
what is a fund mangement industry?what are the trends and issues in that industry?

The overall goal of emergency management is to?
By: scott | 24-09-2008
the overall goal of emergency management is to?

Q&A Powered by:

Latest Project Management Articles

Project Management – the Career for You?
By: projectmanuk | 17/11/2008
Project Management is an increasingly popular career choice for young graduates. According to statistics produced by the Middlesex University National Centre for Project Management, 1.5 – 2 million people earn their living as Project Managers in the UK alone.

Microsoft Project Training - Where Do I Start?
By: Steve Twine | 10/11/2008
Microsoft Project is the world's most popular project management software - but even regular users would often benefit from a better understanding of its full capabilities. Moreover new reporting and communications features in the 2007 release are well worth understanding.

Automation Infatuation-mobile Work Place Automation Makes Chemical Plant Operations More Reliable and Efficient
By: Brady Moritz | 06/11/2008
Throughout the chemical process industry, it’s difficult to think about plant monitoring without visualizing personnel on daily rounds laboriously filling out paper log sheets. Besides being a manual-intensive routine, this traditional monitoring approach primarily focuses only on documentation.

Energy Independence for 800 Year Old Mill on Remote Italian Island
By: Beth Shady | 30/10/2008
Pacific Solar Radiant, Inc. a Santa Cruz based design/build mechanical engineering, plumbing and heating company traveled to a remote Italian island to make an 800 year old mill completely sustainable and off-grid.

How to Build a Library
By: Samuel Bryant | 29/10/2008
When identifying a need for a library a person must identify the needs to the organization or community.

Dust Collectors
By: Oleg Chetchel | 28/10/2008
The use of centrifugal force to throw a dust particle to the periphery of an air stream has been used in the cyclone collector for many years. Dry centrifugal dust collectors can be divided into two basic groups cataloged by their effectiveness in removal of smaller dust particles.

Pacific Timesheet Announces New Iphone Support
By: Jason Trend | 25/10/2008
Pacific Timesheet announces its leading project timesheet software is the first to support the Apple iPhone.

How You Can Make Huge Amount of Money Over the Internet
By: Eddiee | 21/10/2008
It would also help if you can identify their buying power (to see if they can afford your products), their online behavior (to easily make your marketing strategies more focused), and their preferences. Check on your competitors. You can stay on top of the game if you know the strengths and weaknesses of those people that you are up against. Identify the elements that they are using in creating and selling their products online and top them by exerting more efforts and energy on your product cr

More from Tim Bryce

Matrimonial Territorialism
By: Tim Bryce | 29/10/2008 | Marriage
Understanding the boundaries in a marriage.

Moral Decay
By: Tim Bryce | 14/10/2008 | Ethics
Discusses how Moral Decay affects business.

Going it Alone?
By: Tim Bryce | 26/09/2008 | Entrepreneurship
Discusses the differences in working for Big/Small businesses.

Recognizing the Peter Principle
By: Tim Bryce | 16/07/2008 | Management
Describes how to identify the attributes of the Peter Principle.

A Corporate Policy for Personal Electronic Devices
By: Tim Bryce | 09/07/2008 | Management
Describes a proposed policy for controlling personal electronic devices in the workplace.

Socialistic Management
By: Tim Bryce | 02/07/2008 | Management
Describes the problems of "flexible management."

System Design Backwards
By: Tim Bryce | 04/06/2008 | Programming
System Design technique which promotes "design correctness."

Stepwise Refinement
By: Tim Bryce | 29/05/2008 | Programming
Discusses the concept of refining a design using a blueprint-like approach.

Article Categories

Need Help?

Sign up for our email newsletter

Receive updates, enter your email below

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (3.24, 3)

Estimating by Percentages

Article Comments

Related Articles

Got a Question? Ask.

Latest Project Management Articles

More from Tim Bryce

Need Help?

Site Links

Webmasters

Business Info

Sign up for our email newsletter