 |
Haryana’s Apartment Law on Shaky Ground
Author: Property  | Posted: 12-05-2008 | Comments: 1 | Views: 54 | Rating: (111)  (?) 
Twenty-five years after its enactment, two notifications and one amendment later, the Haryana Apartment Ownership Act (HAOA), which seeks to regulate the development and administration of group housing colonies in the state, desperately needs a re-look. The law was passed when the first condominium to come up in Gurgaon was still another six years away. With no local know how, the government drew perfunctorily on the experience of other states.
Lackadaisical drafting lead to a host of conflicts between the promoters and apartment buyers. An opportunity to correct the situation in light of ground experience, which arose in 2002, when the Act was amended to bring commercial complexes under its purview, was not made use of.
The augury was not right for HAOA from day one. After the legislature passed it in 1983, it took the state government three years to notify it in the official gazette. Then, it was discovered, that the wrong department had notified it! It took another 11 years to rectify this error, and re-notify it. And the reason, it is commonly believed, was that the law, as its acronym suggests, is a ‘hawooa’ for the builders and they resisted its implementation for as long as they could.
The basic premise of HAOA is that each complex will eventually be transferred to and administered by elected representatives of the residents. That means that the colonizers will have to part with lucrative common areas and facilities, which they are loath to do and which is the single major cause of conflict between them and residents’ associations.
In Gurgaon, the first city in the state to get self-contained, promoter-constructed colonies, well known complexes such as Silver Oaks, Heritage City, Garden Estate and Central Park are embroiled in disputes over who will eventually own and run common facilities such as shops, school or club, constructed as a part of these condos.
The builders have not followed a consistent policy. Wherever the residents’ associations are perceived to be ‘friendly’, these areas have been handed over to them. Where they are not so considered, either rival bodies have been floated, or the colonizers have retained these facilities.
What helps the builders is that the law itself is double-faced. While its spirit demands that all areas within the complex, other than private residential units, should be common, collective properties of the buyers, there is a provision in HAOA which gives the builders the discretion to include in the ‘transfer declaration’ whatever is to be handed over, and what they wish to retain in their own possession, or sell separately as commercial properties.
And this despite the fact that the law talks about ‘profits’ generated for the associations from ‘common areas’. For Som Vihar complex in Delhi, for example, shop rentals are a major source of revenue for the residents’ body.
Much time and effort can be saved if this aspect of the law can be clarified, for the future if not retrospectively. It goes without saying that the spirit of condominium living would be wrecked if outsiders with crass commercial interests were allowed in. There are other defects in the law. For example, it states that contribution to common expenses and voting rights in any colony will be in the ratio of the respective values of all units (clause 11f). In a colony in which there are 300 flats, there could be 300 values because of differences in the location, size and floor of each apartment.
The model apartment act circulated by the union Ministry of Urban Development, in 1992, specifies only ‘built-up area’ and not ‘value’ as the basis of voting rights, expense contribution and sharing of profits. The same clarification was issued some years ago in the case of Garden Estate, which brought down the number of ‘values’ from 373 to less than 10. But this was through an executive order. The law still harps on ‘value’ as the determining factor.
Again, rule 48 under the Act says: “the Secretary may retain in his personal custody an amount not exceeding Rs 100 for petty expenses.” Most privately developed group housing colonies in the state would have annual budgets of over crores of rupees. How can any such association be ever administered with a ‘petty cash’ holding of just Rs 100? Even in 1983, when the law was first drafted, this would have been impractical. Twenty-five years is enough time to assess the working of any legislation, especially if it covered virgin territory to start with.
It is about time that the government undertook a review of HAOA (and along with it, its big brother, the Haryana Development and Regulation of Urban Areas Act, 1975) to make them more user friendly and eliminate potential areas of conflict between developers, buyers and the government.
And this time, involve all parties concerned in the exercise, instead of just a few bureaucrats undertaking the task and the responsibility on their own.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/real-estate-articles/haryanas-apartment-law-on-shaky-ground-411332.html
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Article Comments
|
|
|
0
1. SANJOY BANKA (05:14, 03.06.2008)
|
Related Articles
Various National Real Estate Developers Beeline for Chandigarh
By: Property | 16/01/2008 | Business
Chandigarh is soon to emerge as one of the most sought after tier-III cities in the next 5 years in terms of commercial, industrial and residential sectors. With major IT companies foraying into the region along with national as well as international developers to meet the expected demand of quality residential and commercial space.
Lusting for Lukhnow
By: Property | 10/03/2008 | Real Estate
Saeed Anwar, an NRI from Dubai, wanted a house in his hometown Lucknow. He bought two plots for Rs 3.5 million ($880,000) in 2005, which are together worth Rs 30 million today. With returns as high as this, many Gulf NRIs are investing in the city’s real estate.
$30 Bn Fdi to Flow Into Realty in 10 Yrs: Assocham
By: Property | 17/06/2008 | Real Estate
New Delhi, June 15: With the real estate sector witnessing a steady growth of more than 30 per cent, Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) worth 30 billion dollars is expected to flow into the domestic market in the next 10 years, an Assocham study says.
Bonanza for Old Mumbai Firms
By: Property | 20/01/2008 | Real Estate
The Maharashtra government’s decision to repeal the Urban Land Ceiling and Regulation Act (ULCRA) in order to obtain funds under the Jawaharlal Nehru Urban Renewal Mission has spelt a bonanza for some of the oldest companies in the city. According to real estate consultancy Knight Frank India in Mumbai alone as much as 17,000 acres of prime land will be released across the city. Others estimate the amount of land to be released at 30,000 acres.
Harvard Eyes Indian Realty Sector With Corporate Programme
By: Property | 12/03/2008 | Real Estate
New Delhi, March 10 (IANS) Eyeing the “explosive” realty market in India, the Harvard Business School (HBS) is set to offer a short duration certificate programme to top executives of real estate industry - but at a stiff fee of Rs.297,000 ($7,310). The Ivy League university will offer the four-day-long programme at Hyderabad Convention Centre beginning June 17.
Deutsche Bank Arm Buys Stake in Golden Gate
By: Property | 23/01/2008 | Real Estate
RREEF, the global alternative investment management business of Deutsche Bank, advised by Deutsche Asset Management (India), has made its first real estate investment in India. RREEF has nearly completed the purchase of an undisclosed stake in Bangalore and Hyderabad-based real estate development company, Golden Gate Properties, for $70 million (Rs 273.5 crore).
Dubai Properties Targets High Net-worth Indian Investors at Mumbai Extravaganza 2008
By: Property | 14/03/2008 | Real Estate
Mumbai Extravaganza offered a unique platform for international real estate institutions as well as developers to launch and promote new products. Apart from high net worth individuals, the high life show also attracted professional advisors such as lawyers, bankers, brokers, top management and decision makers of Mumbai´s leading corporations, successful entrepreneurs and celebrities.
Mundra Growth Impresses Singapore Indian Chamber of Commerce Team
By: Property | 25/06/2008 | Real Estate
AHMEDABAD: A delegation of the Singapore Indian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, currently on a trip to Gujarat, on Thursday visited the Mundra port and other facilities being developed there in the private sector.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Real Estate Articles
One of the Suitable Places for Real Estate Investment: Faridabad
By: Matinez | 21/08/2008
Some of the renowned developers from Delhi and its neighboring cities, such as Eldeco Group, Ansals, Omaxe, Parsvnath Developers and so on are reaching Faridabad to start new high end projects that include integrated townships, shopping malls cum multiplexes, residential dwellings, group housing projects, IT parks and modern office spaces.
Jacuzzi Types and Styles
By: Ed Terran | 21/08/2008
You have decided to buy a Jacuzzi for your home. Have you done your homework to see what style you are going to purchase? If not, you may want to learn a few things about these oversized bathtubs before you actually purchase one.
There are bathtub, portable, steam room, hot tub,...
Some Support Talat and Some Do Not
By: Linda Cartwright | 21/08/2008
Efforts to solve the Cyprus issue are being evaluated in different ways in Turkey. While the Turkish Government supports the Turkish Government supports the Turkish Cypriot President Talat's efforts, the main opposition party (CHP) has criticized Talat after a long period.
Orders to the ambassadors from Babacan
Turkey's Minister of foreign Affairs...
Different Types Of Ceramic Tiles For Bathroom, Kitchen.
By: Ed Terran | 21/08/2008
Everyone has gotten into the craze of ceramic tiles lately. This is what they want on their floors, walls, and especially the bathroom area. When it comes to shopping for the type that you want installed, prepare yourself to be overwhelmed. The different types and manufacturers will astound you.
These tiles...
Bathtub Sizes, Types, And Styles
By: Ed Terran | 21/08/2008
Your bathroom can often be one the simple luxuries you enjoy every day at an affordable price. In fact, a well styled bathroom can add value to your house. A well selected bathroom is central to the utility and ambience of your bathroom, so think carefully before you buy one.
When...
New Range of UK Style Mortgages to be Expanded
By: Mark Smalls | 21/08/2008
The range of UK - style mortgages being offered to British and Irish citizens interested in buying property in North Cyprus is set to be expanded.
British company Lewis Finance says the scheme, which is already receiving a lot of interest from expats and people looking to buy holiday homes on...
Chennai's Expanding Real Estate Market
By: George Gonigal | 21/08/2008
Chennai is experiencing an extensive real estate growth in past one year. Chennai real estate developers are having a good business deal happening during this period of time.
Mortgage Bill by End of Year to Boost Property Market in Northern Cyprus
By: Linda Cartwright | 20/08/2008
Sungur: A Mortgage Bill has been proposed, for approval by the end of this year, in Northern Cyprus.
The plans are set to boost property market, and some experts suggest that the move will also benefit ex-pats.
A draft mortgage bill prepared by the Estate Agents Union has been presented to the...
More from Property
Bangalore Real Estate: Buyers Hesitant, Expect Prices to Fall
By: Property | 07/07/2008 | Real Estate
Bangalore, July 6 There is good demand in the real estate sector, but it has not translated into successful transactions because people are hesitant to buy now expecting a fall in prices in the future, said Mr Kishore Jain, Managing Director, Jain Heights and Structures Pvt Ltd, a Bangalore-based real estate company.
Realty Dreams of Small, Mid-sized Cos Crumble
By: Property | 01/07/2008 | Real Estate
MUMBAI: Grappling with a slowdown across segments, the Indian property market is heading towards the next phase of consolidation. Liquidity crunch in the real estate market is beginning to drive many mid-sized and small developers to scrounge for cover.
Mundra Growth Impresses Singapore Indian Chamber of Commerce Team
By: Property | 25/06/2008 | Real Estate
AHMEDABAD: A delegation of the Singapore Indian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, currently on a trip to Gujarat, on Thursday visited the Mundra port and other facilities being developed there in the private sector.
$30 Bn Fdi to Flow Into Realty in 10 Yrs: Assocham
By: Property | 17/06/2008 | Real Estate
New Delhi, June 15: With the real estate sector witnessing a steady growth of more than 30 per cent, Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) worth 30 billion dollars is expected to flow into the domestic market in the next 10 years, an Assocham study says.
Trikona Raises $150 Mn From German Firm, Offers Stake in Indian Projects
By: Property | 11/06/2008 | Real Estate
Chennai, Jun 9 Trikona Capital Limited, one of the leading fund management firm for institutional investment in Indian real estate and infrastructure, announced that it has extended its relationship with SachsenFonds Holdings GmbH, a German fund manager with $7.5 billion under management, in a $150 million deal that includes minority stakes of current Trikona assets and investments in new projects, including a $40 million housing project at Mumbai.
Bank of Baroda Enters Into Memorandum of Understanding With Dubai Properties
By: Property | 14/05/2008 | Real Estate
Bank of Baroda, India’s international bank has entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with Dubai Properties, the region’s leading real estate company, whereby the bank will provide home finance to buyers of residential units in a number of Dubai Properties’ projects across the UAE.
Mahindras to Drive Into Low-cost Housing Projects
By: Property | 08/05/2008 | Real Estate
Mahindra Lifespaces Developers (MLDL), the housing and real estate arm of the $ 7.5 billion (Rs 30,566 crore) Mahindra Group, is planning to enter the business of building low-cost houses for the middle-income group. Low-cost houses have become a fad among young people, as they are available at an affordable cost of Rs 25-30 lakh.
Real Estate Mfs and Reits Come Cheap
By: Property | 06/05/2008 | Real Estate
They say bureaucracy in India can be slower than the most patient snail. So, more than seven years after the proposal was first mooted, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) came out with its draft guidelines for real estate mutual funds (MFs). This move has brought much joy and relief to the MF industry.
|
|
Finance 
