Sperm donation is a topical issue, and one which has undoubtedly split national and international opinion down on both sides of the fence. In relation to artificial insemination, the act of a man donating sperm creates a situation whereby couples with fertility problems raise the products of the donated sperm. Whilst this kind of solution can be a godsend to childless families, it nevertheless sparks an emotional and moral debate over the role of the sperm donor to his eventual biological child, dredging up the old issues of nature and nurture and the importance of biological as opposed to artificial family relationships. Furthermore with the potential confusion this can cause for the child in later life, and the advancing relationship between DNA testing and paternity, sperm donation continues to be a hotly contested subject.
Arguments on both sides
On one side of the fence is the argument that a child, regardless of any other factors, has an inherent right to see both of his biological parents. Certain opinions suggest that the natural connection is far stronger than anything that can be artificially created, and that as such both the parent and the child have an in-built right to maintain contact with one another. However this view point has fallen to a number of robust criticisms. Firstly, in the context of sperm donation this produces all kinds of policy problems. Few would argue it desirable to have the ability to trace a sperm donor - sperm donation is not a commitment to fatherhood. Likewise the sperm donor should have no direct link to the child for fear that this may disrupt the family unit and hinder the child's upbringing.
Secondly, rights correlate directly with responsibilities according to the influential theory, albeit in a judicial context, known as the Hohfeld schema. Where then, do the rights of the sperm donor correlate with responsibilities? Whilst there is a genetic link, there is no paternal link - that job's already taken, thus the sperm donor has nothing to contribute to the bargain aside from his common genetic materials.
On the flip side, the suggestion stands that children should be allowed to grow up with their family units, and that biological relationships through sperm donation should be kept anonymous for policy reasons and to prevent eventual issues with tracking in later life. However to counter this, why shouldn't a child's biological father have the right to contact and access, if not at a distance, with his child? Sharing the same genes, the characteristics of the father could be adapted through DNA testing (genetic) to work out whether the child will be subject to the same medical problems or temperament issues, which could be beneficial to treating illnesses.
Sperm donator anonymity and DNA Paternity Testing
Paternity testing and DNA testing in general have become far more widespread in recent years, which could eventually lead to the issues of sperm donator anonymity being further jeopardised since a DNA paternity test will confirm with certainty who the biological father is of the child. Until then, however, the debate over the rights and responsibilities of the sperm donator in relation to his biological child looks set to rage on.
Related Articles
Dna Testing for Determining Legal Rights
By: Grant Kretzer | 21/05/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing is becoming of increasing importance in both civil and criminal legal circles. In the field of private law, it is often important to be able to determine family relationships for financial reasons, or to enforce a range of other obligations.
Dna Testing for Infidelity
By: Grant Kretzer | 21/05/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing is an most widely known for its use in DNA Paternity testing, which is most commonly used for the identification of a biological relationship between an alleged father and child.
Dna Testing to Find Your Ancestors
By: Grant Kretzer | 21/05/2008 | Relationships
The use of DNA testing for determining a person’s ancestry is becoming more and common. By linking your maternal DNA (mitochondrial DNA) and your paternal DNA (the y-chromosome), these ancestry databases are effectively able to link you to other people to whom you may be related and thereby determining to some degree your ancestral lineage and where your ancestors came from.
The Basics of Forensic Dna Testing and the Ethics Behind it
By: Grant Kretzer | 21/05/2008 | Relationships
Although DNA testing is something that is used primarily by scientists who can use and interpret DNA and the results of testing processes, DNA in recent years has become a fantastic tool for use in forensic science.
How to Perform a Dna Sample Collection for Dna Testing
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing is most accurate method for confirming biological relationships between individuals. The most common form of testing nowadays is DNA Paternity testing, which is done to confirm the relationship between an alleged Father (and sometimes Mother) and a child.
The Dna Testing Process
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing is becoming increasingly used to determine genetic links between individuals as a highly accurate and individual way of identifying people and their relationships with one another.
Paternity Testing on Absent Fathers
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing is one of the most conclusive ways available to determine paternity of any given child. By taking a sample of DNA from both the alleged father and from the child in question, high-tech DNA profiling techniques are used to match reference points across genetic markers on both samples which can lead to an accurate determination of where a genetic relationship exists.
Twin Zygosity Dna Testing
By: Kevin Camilleri | 28/03/2008 | Relationships
The Twin Zygosity DNA test can determine whether twins are identical or fraternal. Understanding whether a twin is identical or fraternal is not always easy due to possible similar physical resemblance even between fraternal twins.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Relationships Articles
Emotional Intimacy
By: Margaret Paul, Ph.d. | 21/08/2008
Experiencing emotional intimacy with others is one of the most satisfying experiences of life. Emotional intimacy, or a sense of deep connection with another person or a group of people, occurs when each person is completely open hearted and devoted to taking 100% responsibility for their own feelings and needs....
Why You Can Still Feel Lonely in a Crowd
By: Rick Cowles | 20/08/2008
You have been invited to a party, and you know only the host and hostess. Other people seem to be friendly and know each other. No one seems to be interested in you.
Great Sex But Dont Pump The Dump
By: David Wygant | 20/08/2008
So, you're dating a woman now whose only sexual experiences have been with men that are pump and dumpers. For those of you who don't know what a pump and dumper is: it's what I call 'minutemen.'
Not the minutemen from the Revolutionary War.. They get in, they thrust their hips,...
Get On Top By Learning How To Talk Dirty To My Boyfriend
By: Erik Willis | 20/08/2008
Guys like to walk about town thinking that sex is all important for them but don't seem to think what it means to a woman. Well, we know how important it is to us girls but we just aren't as blatant or as basic as men are. It seems as...
Do Indian Singles Meet Their Spouce Quicker Now?
By: Billy Baker | 19/08/2008
A helpful article aimed at single Indian men and women who want to choose their own husband or wife. Indicates the benefits and usage of Indian dating sites for this purpose.
12 Mistakes That Prevent a Good Photoshot
By: Lilia Parker | 19/08/2008
Tips on how to receive a solicited reply in a marriage site. What a good quality, professional photographs can do for your future?
Online Indian Dating Exposed
By: Billy Baker | 19/08/2008
Indian dating in the past has been plagued with doubt and suspicion. This article clears up some of the myths and opens the doors to helpful hints and facts about online Indian dating.
How to Find a Long Lost Loved One or Friend
By: Ed Opperman | 18/08/2008
Have you been thinking about someone you've lost touch with? I bet they're thinking about you too. It's time to be reunited.
More from Kevin Camilleri
Twin Zygosity Dna Testing
By: Kevin Camilleri | 28/03/2008 | Relationships
The Twin Zygosity DNA test can determine whether twins are identical or fraternal. Understanding whether a twin is identical or fraternal is not always easy due to possible similar physical resemblance even between fraternal twins.
The Legal Impact of Parentage
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
When one thinks of being a parent the initial points for consideration tend to be financial (can we afford it?), practical (how will our lives change?) and pragmatic (what do we need to do to prepare?). However, too few people think of parentage as a legal relationship, subject to a variety of different laws across a number of different areas.
Dna Testing Definitions
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing and the whole process that goes with it can be confusing for anyone, particularly if you're never experienced the process before.
The Legal Impact of Parentage
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
When one thinks of being a parent the initial points for consideration tend to be financial (can we afford it?), practical (how will our lives change?) and pragmatic (what do we need to do to prepare?). However, too few people think of parentage as a legal relationship, subject to a variety of different laws across a number of different areas. Whilst some of the legal effects are positive, some require a greater understanding of the nature of paternity in order to fathom whether or not the chi
Paternity Testing on Absent Fathers
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing is one of the most conclusive ways available to determine paternity of any given child. By taking a sample of DNA from both the alleged father and from the child in question, high-tech DNA profiling techniques are used to match reference points across genetic markers on both samples which can lead to an accurate determination of where a genetic relationship exists.
Reasons for Dna Testing
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing is becoming more and more popular as a way of catching criminals and establishing family relationships (usually in the context of paternity through DNA paternity testing).
The Dna Testing Process
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing is becoming increasingly used to determine genetic links between individuals as a highly accurate and individual way of identifying people and their relationships with one another.
How to Perform a Dna Sample Collection for Dna Testing
By: Kevin Camilleri | 19/03/2008 | Relationships
DNA testing is most accurate method for confirming biological relationships between individuals. The most common form of testing nowadays is DNA Paternity testing, which is done to confirm the relationship between an alleged Father (and sometimes Mother) and a child.
Relationships 
