 |
Does God Heal Those Who Pray or Do We Heal Ourselves?
Author: David E. Comings, M.D.  | Posted: 13-07-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 27 | Rating: (94)  (?) 
We have all heard stories of how people who were afflicted with serious diseases prayed to God and were healed. Despite the fact that many times prayer does not help, in those cases where it was effective this strengthens the faith of those who prayed and further seals their belief that God exists. This is especially the case where faith healers treat hundreds of people at a time, seemingly producing miraculous cures. While some of these "cures" are not valid, at other times real healing has taken place. Does this prove God exists and is doing the healing, or are there other explanations?
Knowledge that the body can heal itself in a fashion that is above and beyond the normal reparative mechanisms has been gaining greater appreciation in the past half century. This process is called "the placebo effect." For years doctors associated placebo effect with being "all in your mind." However, a number of remarkable studies have now shown that the placebo effect is a classical example of a mind-body interaction and that the effect has a biological and physiological basis.
The placebo effect is so powerful that the Federal Drug Administration (FDA) requires that all new drugs be evaluated using double blind studies where the active drug and a placebo are compared. Before pharmaceutical companies can market a new drug it has to be shown to be significantly more effective than the placebo. This requirement has resulted in the rejection of hundreds of drugs. Double blind studies have also shown that some surgical treatments are also ineffective. Two of the most notable are tying off an artery in the chest wall (internal mammary artery) to treat coronary artery disease, and debridement of the cartilage in the treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee.
How does the placebo effect work? A major part of the puzzle was solved by a 1978 study of dental anesthesia in patients undergoing treatment of impacted molars. They were given the usual anesthesia for the procedure but this wore off after 2 hours. They were then told that they would receive an injection of a powerful pain-killer. Some were given the opioid drug, morphine, while others were given a placebo. A significant proportion of those given a placebo had the same relief of pain as those given the opioid drug morphine. The placebo-responders were then given Naloxone, a drug that eliminates the action of narcotic drugs like morphine by blocking the opioid receptors. Remarkably, the placebo-responders reported an increase in their pain. These studies indicated that the placebo effect was due to the release of the body's natural opioids, called endorphins. These studies have been replicated many times.
Studies using functional MRI were undertaken to further identify the mechanism of the placebo effect. These studies showed that an additional part of the placebo effect is derived from the activation of the prefrontal cognitive or thought centers. This in turn produced a decrease in activation of the pain matrix involved in the processing of pain signals throughout the brain.
If the blinded placebo studies were carried out in a way that the subjects were unaware that the placebo was being given, it did not work. This showed that a critical aspect of the placebo effect is the "expectation of relief" of pain or of illness. This is why the setting is so critical for an effective placebo effect. For physicians, this setting consists of a white coat, a stethoscope, diplomas on the wall, and the expected clinical setting. For witch doctors it consists of an ominous mask, rattles, dances, fire and smoke. For the faith healer it consists of large enthusiastic crowds, the presence of hundreds of others who seem to be healed, dramatic gestures such as pushing and falling backward, and loud calls for the helping hand of God.
A further testimony to the power of the placebo effect is that doctors, shamans, witch doctors and related individuals have been perceived as effective healers for thousands of years despite the fact that truly effective drugs such as antibiotics, antidepressants, anti-psychotics and others have been available only in the past 70 years.
If a person truly believes they will be healed - they very often are. It is not God but our own bodies that are doing the healing.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/religion-articles/does-god-heal-those-who-pray-or-do-we-heal-ourselves-482595.html
About the Author:David E. Comings, M.D., author of Did Man Create God? is a world renown physician, human geneticist, and neuroscientist, past president of the American Society of Human Genetics and head of the Department of Medical Genetics at the City of Hope National Medical Center for 37 years. See Did Man Create God.
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
What chapter in the Bible and what verses ...
By: DRigolet | 16-08-2008
What chapter in the Bible and what verses describes sins that God detests
What is a Raboni? How is one honored?
By: Zee | 15-08-2008
what is a Raboni? How is one honored?
Library Scinece
By: latoshacompton | 15-08-2008
I would like to know how long is the library science degree program. And alos what classes do you have to take?
I'm a man married for thirty five yrs. I had an ...
By: judah5769 | 15-08-2008
I'm a man married for thirty five yrs. I had an affair with a woman outside of the marraige. During Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur I plan on asking for forgiveness by (Hashem/wife). What will be the punishment for the one who allowed me to have this affair, should I ask for forgiveness from her also?
What is the religion of the three guys that swam ...
By: Marty Funk | 15-08-2008
What is the religion of the three guys that swam with Michael Phelps,in the 4X100
Are Jehovah Witnesses a Cult?
By: monkeyface | 15-08-2008
Are the Jehovah Witnesses a cult? If so, please explain why?
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Religion Articles
This is Allah (38) Does Allah Charge Any Soul Beyond Its Scope?
By: Safaa Abdel-Aziz | 13/10/2008
Who is Allah? Verses 7:42-43 of the Noble Quran talk about: 1) Does Allah Charge any Soul Beyond its Scope? 2) The Outcome of those who Believe in Muhammad and Perform Righteous Deeds, 3) The Believers shall Abide in the Paradise Forever Never to Die or be Removed, 4) Who are the Rightful owners of the Paradise? 5) What if the Believers who Abide in the Paradise have had Rancor between them in the life of this world? And 6) What the Believers will say once they Have Settled in the Paradise?
Spiritual Anchoring in Times of Difficulty
By: Julie Redstone | 13/10/2008
There is a great need for spiritual anchoring in times of turbulence and change. Anchoring in a deeper truth helps us to weather the currents of emotion that pass through us due either to external events that we experience directly, or to taking in the reactions of others to these...
Religious Jewelry
By: Jayne Waldorf | 13/10/2008
I am not about to start discussing religion in this article. I think that beliefs are a personal matter. If you are interested in religious jewellery because it reinforces your faith or because you find it pleasing to wear or any other reason then that's ok by you so it...
Entering the Dark Room
By: Bobby Keating | 12/10/2008
Alzheimer's disease is devastating, not only to the patient but also to the care giver. How do I handle the heartache?
Higher Purpose in Life
By: 104inc.com | 12/10/2008
My comments may be a bit controversial and it may enrage people but I as a religious person and trying to evaluate the purpose of life? From a logical standpoint I cannot figure it out. We kill and pillage and rape in the name of religion and God. Yet if God loves all of us why in turn would we not love each other unconditionally?
This is Allah (37) How Does Allah Requite the Guilty and the Evildoers?
By: Safaa Abdel-Aziz | 12/10/2008
Many people do not know Allah. This series is an attempt to help them in order to know their Creator.
Verses 7:39-41 of the Noble Quran talk about: 1) How does Allah requite the guilty and the evildoers?, 2) What is the outcome of those who deny Muhammad and the Quran?, 3) The gates of Heaven will not be opened for the Souls of those who…, 4) When Allah Shall Say: so taste the doom for what you used to earn? And 5) How will be the bed and the coverings over the Disbelievers in the Afterlife?
Influence With the Gospel
By: Steve Bremner | 11/10/2008
Just some thoughts on the influence we can have on people.
Divine Healing is Mechanical, not Relational
By: Steve Bremner | 11/10/2008
Upon reading through the book of Matthew once a few years ago, I came to some thoughts I'm going to share with you today that are still relevant in my life, and coupled with something I read in Spiritual Authority by Watchman Nee.
More from David E. Comings, M.D.
Do Atheists Have to be Anti-Faith or Anti-Religion?
By: David E. Comings, M.D. | 13/07/2008 | Religion
Since the religious terrorism of 9/11 a number of books have appeared by atheists that are staunchly anti-faith and anti-religion, placing many of the evils of modern society at the feet of religion. These include Richard Dawkin's The God Delusion, Sam Harris' The End of Faith, Daniel Dennet's Breaking the...
Is Morality a God Given or an Inborn Trait?
By: David E. Comings, M.D. | 07/07/2008 | Religion
The idea that man needs God to tell us how to behave morally, to be kind and thoughtful toward our fellow man, to aid others without any promise of benefit to ourselves, is a central tenet of most of the major religions. To emphasize the point, we are told that...
Is There a Simple Solution to the Problem of Why God Allows Evil to Occur?
By: David E. Comings, M.D. | 30/06/2008 | Religion
One of the most difficult questions for priests, ministers, and theologians to answer is - Why does a kind, compassionate, personal God that answers prayers and looks out for our personal welfare, allow so much evil to occur in the world? This is often called "the problem of evil." As...
Did Man Create God?
By: David E. Comings, M.D. | 21/06/2008 | Religion
In an era when politicians must prove they are religious to get elected and the proclamations of their ministers can get them into trouble, when schools are urged to teach creationism, when presidents and main stream movies proclaim the virtues of Intelligent Design, when fundamentalists want to destroy Western civilization...
|
|
News and Society 
