Discussing Philosophy in a Productive Way

| Posted: 22-01-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 16 | Rating: (55)

(?)

When discussing complex topics such as philosophy, skillful conversation becomes even more important. If conversationalists fail to use good technique, then they will not communicate with each other effectively, and the conversation will become unproductive. Let me suggest some ways to make and keep a conversation productive when discussing philosophy.

Listen - Most importantly, you need to listen as well as you can to the other people in the discussion. Many people talk too much and listen too little. Ironically, if you talk too much, you will have a lot of trouble expressing yourself. If you listen well, you can express yourself better because you can tailor your response to what the person has already said. Additionally, if you listen to others intently, they will likely return the favor. If you do not listen to them and just try to talk over them, then they will likely do the same to you.

Ask Questions - Plato's dialogues show how Socrates used questions to have productive philosophical conversations with others. The Socratic Method can come in great use in discussions of philosophy. Asking questions will help you better understand the other speakers, and it will cause them to express their contentions more clearly to you. That will greatly reduce misunderstandings. Additionally, asking questions makes you seem genuinely interested in the other person's ideas. Making disagreeing statements, instead of asking questions, may make the other person feel attacked and may make you seem preachy, both of which will make the discussion less productive.

Speak Clearly - This may seem obvious, but many people instead try to show off or make their ideas seem stronger by using more complex language. However, you will have most productive conversation by having the least misunderstandings, which you can do by expressing yourself as clearly as possible. Using concise, simple, and specific phrasing will usually help you express yourself clearly. Rambling, over-elaboration and the unnecessary use of "big words" will make you less clear. Additionally, you can express yourself most clearly when you match the formality of your speech or writing to the formality of the situation. In other words, use formal phrasing in a formal situation and more informal phrasing in a more informal setting.

Speak Nicely and Politely - If the conversation turns into a contest, or if any of the speakers feel angry or offended, it will greatly reduce the philosophical productivity of the discussion. A discussion about philosophy can quickly degenerate into a name-calling, insult-throwing fight. The other person will listen to you more if they feel more comfortable and respected. Do not just speak as nicely as you must in order to keep the conversation philosophical; instead, speak as nicely, respectfully, and politely as you can. Avoid insults, name-calling, or offensiveness as much as possible. Also, especially if you disagree, try thanking the other person for discussing the topic with you.

If you genuinely try to have a productive conversation, you almost always will. Most people do philosophy for fun out of interest, so why not try to have a productive conversation when discussing philosophy?

Whatever you do, good luck and have fun!

Rate this Article:

Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).

Article Tags: Philosophy, Philosophers, Conversation, Discussion, Conversations, Discussions, Philosopher, Discuss, Philosophize

Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/science-articles/discussing-philosophy-in-a-productive-way-312817.html

Print article

Send to friend

Publish this Article

Author feedback

About the Author:

Scott Hughes maintains an internet-based philosophy club at OnlinePhilosophyClub.com. You can discuss philosophy at the Philosophy Forums. It's completely free, and all viewpoints are welcome.

Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free!

Article Comments

Add new Comment

How to Study and Learn About Philosophy
By: Scott Hughes | 25/01/2008 | Philosophy

Philosophy - Can Humans be Perfectly Happy?
By: Scott Hughes | 13/02/2008 | Psychology

Political Philosophy - Why Governments Overspend
By: Scott Hughes | 21/02/2008 | Politics

Start Philosophizing
By: Scott Hughes | 01/10/2007 | Science

Participating in Philosophical Discussions in Everyday Life
By: Scott Hughes | 12/11/2007 | Philosophy

A Philosophical Exploration of the Idea of the Self
By: Scott Hughes | 21/11/2007 | Philosophy

Preparing for a Date is the Key to Starting a Conversation
By: Joshua Uebergang | 09/04/2007 | Dating
Dating related articles, advice for dating, dating sites and habits all in the dating articles.

The Clarity of Moral Nihilism
By: Scott Hughes | 27/12/2007 | Philosophy

Got a Question? Ask.

Ask the community a question about this article:

Frequently Asked Questions

What does euthyphro first propose as a definition ...
By: dotsonwife | 30-08-2008
what does euthyphro first propose as a definition of piety?

Discuss the growth process in animals.
By: ctrakme | 24-08-2008
Discuss the growth process in animals.

Are there any most ticklisk contest in nyc
By: janine | 18-08-2008
are there any most ticklisk contest in nyc

Agnostics and atheists in the 18th century
By: IndyMark | 18-08-2008
From an empirical perspective, were there any well-known agnostics or atheists in the eighteenth century?

A matter of taste?
By: Garret | 14-08-2008
why am i so tasty?

What and how are the ways sending scanned email ...
By: Pogi | 04-08-2008
What and how are the ways sending scanned email attachment more than 10mb?

Q&A Powered by:

Latest Science Articles

A Note on Iso 9000 and Iso 14000
By: Mahdi | 05/10/2008
ISO is a federation of national standard institutes of 157 countries on the basis of one member per country. ISO name means International Organization for Standardization. ISO has been developing voluntary technical standards over almost all sectors of business, industry and technology since 1947. The work is carried out by the expert from the concerned industrial, technical and business bodies and may be joined by relevant government agencies, academic and testing laboratories.

Desertification
By: Frank Lee | 05/10/2008
A quick article on desertification, its causes, and its consequences.

Don't Hurt the Feelings of Your Hibiscus!
By: Joel Kontinen | 05/10/2008
A study on plant dignity won the 2008 Ig Noble peace prize. The study claimed that plants might posess inherent dignity

Air Polution Riding Wave of Technological Change
By: Oladokun Sulaiman | 05/10/2008
Article desclibe how air emision is driving recent technological change

Environmental Risk Aversion for Waste Derived Biomass
By: Oladokun Sulaiman | 05/10/2008
This paper will discussed the need to choose waste derived biofuel above all other food sources. The paper will also used risk based environmental philosophy procedure to described risk and risk abatement required to come up with a potential best sustainable bioenergy generation system.

Synthetic Systems Biology
By: PRASANNA BHAGWAN | 04/10/2008
The payoff for systems biology research is not merely abstract mathematical understanding, but empowerment to design new and improved functions via synthetic biology. There are number of exciting and profound issues that are actively investigated, such as robustness of the biological systems, network structures and dynamics and applications to drug discovery etc.

Plastic Surgery: the Mathematics of Beauty
By: Robert | 04/10/2008
Bodily beauty explained according to the principle of the Golden Ratio/Phi

Plastic Surgery Procedures Can Create Wellness for All
By: Robert | 04/10/2008
How plastic surgery changed the outlook of many people’s lives and how it benefits people to have plastic surgery.

More from Scott Hughes

Ethical Philosophy: Altruism and Selfishness
By: Scott Hughes | 23/04/2008 | Philosophy
The self-interestedness supported by pro-selfishness philosophers does not necessarily conflict with the kindness supported by pro-selflessness philosophers.

Why Do People Fear Sex?
By: Scott Hughes | 31/03/2008 | Sexuality
Why do the people in our society tend to have such negative feelings towards sexuality? Why do so many cultures throughout the globe fear and hate sex?

Personal Attacks in Philosophical Discussions
By: Scott Hughes | 18/03/2008 | Psychology
An ad hominem argument consists of replying to a person's argument by merely attacking the character of the person making the argument.

What it Means for an Action to be Immoral
By: Scott Hughes | 07/03/2008 | Philosophy
What does it mean to call an action morally good or morally bad? Different people use those terms to mean very different things.

Philosophy of Politics - We Do not Need Prisons
By: Scott Hughes | 29/02/2008 | Politics
Do prisons really protect people from violence and victimization, or do prisons just make matters worse?

Political Philosophy - Why Governments Overspend
By: Scott Hughes | 21/02/2008 | Politics
Governments engage in many expensive endeavors that have little use or little effectiveness. Unfortunately, taxpayers have to foot the bill.

Corporate Crime Needs More Attention
By: Scott Hughes | 19/02/2008 | Politics
Corporations perform the most major forms of criminal victimization. Corporate crime inflicts far more damage on society than street crime.

Philosophy - Can Humans be Perfectly Happy?
By: Scott Hughes | 13/02/2008 | Psychology
Most people can probably tell you whether or not they feel happy. Nonetheless, the idea of happiness becomes very complex and interesting when we look at it from a philosophical perspective.

Article Categories

Article Marketing

Article Notepad

Stop Duplicate Content

Term Papers

Need Help?

Sign up for our email newsletter

Receive updates, enter your email below

Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2008 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved. (0.14, 17)

Discussing Philosophy in a Productive Way

Article Comments

Related Articles

Got a Question? Ask.

Latest Science Articles

More from Scott Hughes

Need Help?

Site Links

Webmasters

Business Info

Sign up for our email newsletter