 |
Substance Abuse Evaluations in Child Custody Cases
Author: Tom Horvath  | Posted: 29-09-2008 | Comments: 1 | Views: 59 | Rating: (228)  (?) 
Related Videos
The Real Costanza
The real Costanza sued the real Seinfeld over a "show about nothing."...
I make a number of assumptions when conducting a substance use evaluation as part of a litigation process: 1) the individual's use is usually not less than the individual reports, but it might often be more (or much more); 2) inaccurate accusations of substance abuse are common because there is usually little negative consequence for inaccurate accusations; 3) the parties to the litigation, and those connected with them, may provide biased and inaccurate information. Therefore outside corroboration of their reports is essential for determining the extent and consequences of substance use.
As a practical matter, getting outside corroboration (information from sources not connected with the litigation) is difficult because such information may simply not exist, or obtaining it would require work performed by other professionals (such as private investigators) rather than by psychologists. That work would be outside the scope of the psychological evaluation the individual has consented to. An evaluation that obtained outside corroboration could be conducted at great expense, but would require weeks to months of effort and at best would only establish the history of substance problems (or lack of them). Such an evaluation would be appropriate when litigation is only concerned with history and not with the future (as it is in child custody litigation).
In my typical evaluation I document what is reported by the parties, conduct basic psychological and addiction testing, review documentation, and interview collaterals, as appropriate to each case. In some cases I am able to identify reports that are unlikely or impossible (e.g., consuming only 2 beers would not result 90 minutes later in BAL of .22). In some cases the information I obtain allows me to offer a firm diagnostic opinion. However, in most cases I will not have a firm diagnostic opinion, because I will not have sufficient firm evidence.
Even with a firm diagnostic opinion, the prediction of future substance use is problematic. An individual's substance use can change, suddenly, dramatically and without treatment or support group attendance, in response to changes in the environment. Litigation often produces substantial environmental changes, and therefore has the potential to lead to significant decreases (or increases) in substance use. The diagnostic manual (DSM-IV-TR, page 221) recognizes that "some individuals (perhaps 20% or more) with Alcohol Dependence achieve long-term sobriety even without active treatment."
Consequently, if the litigation has a future focus, my normal recommendation is to obtain substance testing on a continuous basis. I will monitor the results of this testing if the court requests it. Random testing might work in some cases, but it allows a significant potential for delay in discovering problems. Such delay is unacceptable when the best interests of children are involved. Depending on the substances of concern, testing involves the individual stopping at a drug testing facility two to three times per week to provide a urine sample. Modifications to the basic plan need to be made if the individual tested is a reportedly moderate drinker, but in some instances such individuals are willing to abstain completely for the sake of eliminating suspicions about their having alcohol problems.
I normally recommend that the testing be paid for by the other party, and continued as long as the other party feels it is worth paying for. Solomon knew that the true mother would only want what was best for her child. Even Solomon did not try, simply based on the reports he received, to determine which mother was telling the truth.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/self-help-articles/substance-abuse-evaluations-in-child-custody-cases-582684.html
About the Author:A. Tom Horvath, Ph.D., ABPP, is a board certified clinical psychologist and president of Practical Recovery (practicalrecovery.com), an addiction treatment facility in La Jolla (San Diego), CA, focusing on collaborative care and self-empowerment. alcohol treatment
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means to drive traffic to your website and promote yourself and your business. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Article Comments
|
|
|
0
1. Suzette Robertson (16:23, 14.10.2008)
|
Related Articles
On Being A SEN (Sleep, Exercise, Nutrition) Master Part 2
By: Tom Horvath | 29/09/2008 | Sports & Fitness
In part 1 of this 2-part series getting a good night's sleep was the focus. Part 2 focuses on exercise and nutrition.
Exercise: The three components of fitness are endurance (of the heart-lungs, or "cardio"), strength and flexibility. The benefits of having a basic level of fitness are numerous: improved mood...
Can Drinking and Drugging Help me Deal With Painful Feelings?
By: Tom Horvath | 29/09/2008 | Self Help
Yes, but...
No one complains about feeling happy! But we don't want to have other, painful feelings. When these feelings arise, one way to respond to them is to drink or drug. One set of painful feelings can be broadly labeled fear or anxiety: "Drugs and/or alcohol helped me cope with...
Can Drinking and Drugging Improve Your Social Life?
By: Tom Horvath | 29/09/2008 | Self Help
Yes, but...
In the first section let's discuss how drugs and alcohol can actually have a beneficial effect on your social life (or at least appear to). In the second section let's discuss why drug and alcohol use can still be a bad idea for you.
One of the most frequent reasons...
The Biggest Risk to Sobriety After Drug Rehab
By: Christin Shire | 04/10/2007 | Health
The day you decide you no longer need aftercare therapies, no longer need to go to meetings, no longer need to see a psychologist; that is the day that the trouble often begins. You may believe that you are ready, that you have beaten your addiction, and that you no longer need to spend so much time in therapy; but they'll tell you you’re wrong, and they KNOW what relapse looks like.
Coping Responsibly With Addiction. Do you Get It?
By: Denny Soinski | 31/01/2007 | Self Help
Some people deal with problems responsibly while others do not. It follows that responsible people who have an addiction will usually seek treatment to help them overcome or minimize the negative consequences of their addiction while most irresponsible addicts will not.
How Much Does Drug Rehab Cost?
By: Christin Shire | 04/10/2007 | Health
Getting accurate drug rehab pricing information off of a Google search is close to impossible, and although you will get hundreds of thousands of pages from thousands and thousands of drug rehabs vying for your entry, almost none of them will reveal how much a stay will actually cost.
The False High of Addiction
By: Denny Soinski | 31/01/2007 | Diseases & Conditions
If you need a “high” in your life, stay away from drugs and alcohol and find healthy sources of excitement and fun. If you are involved in abusing drugs or addicted to drugs, you should get professional help as soon as possible.
The Truth About Rehab Recovery Statistics
By: Christin Shire | 04/10/2007 | Health
Be very careful with rehabs that boast too much. If they lie about that, what else are they lying about?
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
We do care.
By: Kathy | 22-10-2008
drug additions
How do I help someone I love to stop taking drugs and drinking. He is only 17 years old. I'm trying to help him stop.... He is currently sitting in the Juvenile Detention Center for burglary and grand theft. This is not first time he has done this. He is facing being charged as an adult this time and he really needs help.
How much does it cost tax payers per anum to ...
By: Felicia | 16-10-2008
how much does it cost tax payers per anum to simply jail drug offenders?
How have statistics showed change since courts ...
By: Felicia | 16-10-2008
how have statistics showed change since courts started reffering offenders to 12 step programs?
Cout ordered recovery
By: Felicia | 16-10-2008
When did courts start to refer offenders to 12 step programs?
Alcoholism
By: William | 06-10-2008
What is the cause and cure of alcoholism?
Cases in Jefferson County court Alabama involving ...
By: Lauren | 05-10-2008
cases in Jefferson County court Alabama involving Shannon and Clive Berube
Q&A Powered by: 
Latest Self Help Articles
Packrat Syndrome: Do You or Someone You Love Have Any of These Symptoms?
By: Joesph Merton | 16/11/2008
Are you wondering if you or someone you know is a packrat? Read this article and find out.
Find Happiness Helping Others
By: Doug Hart | 16/11/2008
We must think beyond ourselves in order to find true happiness – how can we help others in big way? There are many organizations that make it really easy to help people, here are a few. Join me in giving to others and it will help you to find true happiness, I promise!
Law of Abundance - Keep it Simple and Prosper
By: Timothy Aaron Whiston | 16/11/2008
The law of abundance is a simple concept to grasp and use. And this article will help you live a more abundant, prosperous life in every way.
Use the Law of Attraction in 3 Easy Steps!
By: Timothy Aaron Whiston | 16/11/2008
Start using the law of attraction right now with these three simple steps. Easily bring more success and happiness into your life starting right away. Use The Law Of Attraction - Step 1. Step one to using the law of attraction is to get as happy as possible right here, and right now.
Combining EFT With Other Healing Processes
By: StewartRobertson | 15/11/2008
One of EFT's most useful aspects is its flexibility in working with other energy treatments.
Many clinicians' efforts are to focus their attention on the problem while balancing or remove an obstruction to the body's energy system. This influences them to combine EFT with other procedures. Other kinds of healing bring...
Clinical Hypnosis
By: Daniel Galant | 15/11/2008
Clinical Hypnosis is a procedure in which an individual is taught to enter a state of heightened focus, relaxation and suggestibility. This hypnotic trance state becomes the basis for alleviating or resolving medical and psychological symptoms, as well as enhancing performance and creativity. However, for many people hypnosis conjures up...
EFT Advantages
By: StewartRobertson | 14/11/2008
If you are looking for some medical treatment and you found out that those medical cures were just so expensive that you cannot really afford it, the result would be finding an alternative remedy or treatment for the sickness.
Not every one of us has the strength to survive a tragic...
Achieving Goals in Five Steps
By: Leslie Allan | 14/11/2008
We all want that sense of achievement that comes with reaching our goals. Whether we are working for ourselves or working within a larger organization, we get a deep sense of satisfaction when we accomplish what we set out to do. Some people seem to achieve their objectives without much...
More from Tom Horvath
Teach Teens Drinking Before it Kills Them
By: Tom Horvath | 15/11/2008 | Home & Family
Alcohol prohibition in the US lasted from 1919 to 1933. Prohibition continues for those under age 21. Prohibition was repealed because it was violated so often. Given how much people like to drink, prohibition as a public policy was not realistic. In this article I suggest that we are seeing...
Are Non-12-step Recovery Approaches Effective?
By: Tom Horvath | 14/11/2008 | Medicine
There are many effective alternatives to the 12-step addiction recovery approach. This article will describe the major treatments and support groups that one might choose if interested in a non-12-step (alternative) approach. These alternatives need to be widely known because individuals who might never attend an AA (Alcoholics Anonymous) meeting...
Why Would Someone Choose a Non-12-step Recovery Approach?
By: Tom Horvath | 14/11/2008 | Medicine
If you were a woman with breast cancer, you'd probably want to know that there were several treatment options you had: radical mastectomy, lumpectomy, radiation, chemotherapy, holistic services, nutritional approaches, some combination of these options, or doing nothing, with new options emerging continually. You might be inclined to let your...
Can Drinking and Drugging Improve Your Social Life?
By: Tom Horvath | 29/09/2008 | Self Help
Yes, but...
In the first section let's discuss how drugs and alcohol can actually have a beneficial effect on your social life (or at least appear to). In the second section let's discuss why drug and alcohol use can still be a bad idea for you.
One of the most frequent reasons...
Can Drinking and Drugging Help me Deal With Painful Feelings?
By: Tom Horvath | 29/09/2008 | Self Help
Yes, but...
No one complains about feeling happy! But we don't want to have other, painful feelings. When these feelings arise, one way to respond to them is to drink or drug. One set of painful feelings can be broadly labeled fear or anxiety: "Drugs and/or alcohol helped me cope with...
On Being A SEN (Sleep, Exercise, Nutrition) Master Part 2
By: Tom Horvath | 29/09/2008 | Sports & Fitness
In part 1 of this 2-part series getting a good night's sleep was the focus. Part 2 focuses on exercise and nutrition.
Exercise: The three components of fitness are endurance (of the heart-lungs, or "cardio"), strength and flexibility. The benefits of having a basic level of fitness are numerous: improved mood...
Can You Trust Your Own Judgment In Addiction Recovery?
By: Tom Horvath | 23/05/2008 | Self Help
Addiction recovery requires accomplishing a number of tasks, including:
build and maintain motivation
connect with others
identify and develop alternative coping methods
reduce resentment about changing
identify, understand and cope with craving
build a new, balanced life
lead a life that is purposeful, meaningful and reasonably happy
stay alert for problems and follow through all the way
To accomplish...
The Relationship Between Addiction And Habit
By: Tom Horvath | 21/05/2008 | Self Help
Let's define addiction as repeated involvement with anything, despite excessive costs, because of craving. That sounds similar to habit, with is also repeated involvement with something. What are the differences and similarities between addiction and habit?
Let's start with some examples of what appear to be addiction. A college freshman ends...
|
|
Self Improvement 
