It is common practice for exercisers to take their heart rate after a bout of exercise. Whether running a track interval or performing an aerobics routine, this method is frequently used to monitor the intensity of exercise.
If you are part of an exercise group, common procedure is to wait until everyone has located their pulse (often 15 seconds or so) then to time six, 10 or 15 seconds while everyone counts their own heart beats. You then multiply by the appropriate number (10, 6 or 4, respectively) to arrive at a beats-per-minute value.
However, research has shown that this procedure underestimates heart rates because of the time-lag after the cessation of exercise. In fact, heart rates drop very quickly after exercise ends. This is particularly true for trained athletes.
MANUAL PULSE MEASUREMENT STUDY
A study at the University of Texas at Austin investigated manual heart rate measurement methods by comparing them to actual heart rates as measured by an ECG. The subjects performed exercise sessions at 70% or 85% of their max heart rate. They waited 15 seconds after the end of the session, then counted their pulse for 15 seconds and multiplied by four to get their beats-per-minute count.
At the same time, an ECG measured their actual heart rates at three different times: during the last 10 seconds of exercise; in the first 15 seconds after exercise; then 15 seconds after that.
The manual measurements and the ECG results were then compared.
FINDINGS
The study revealed several things:
1. Both ECG and manual measurements - if taken after the exercise ended - underestimated the heart rate reached during the final 10 seconds of the exercise session.
2. Even the ECG taken immediately after exercise, yielded a heart rate that was 7-9 beats per minute lower than the during-exercise rate. This is because heart rates drop dramatically once exercise ends - especially for trained athletes.
3. The longer the wait before taking a pulse, the less accurate the measurement.
4. Manual methods for measuring pulse rates were fairly accurate, although the radial (wrist) method was less accurate at higher heart rates than the cartotid (neck) method. The radial method yielded results that were too low by about 10 beats per minute.
CONCLUSIONS
1. The best way to measure exercise heart rate is by measuring it during exercise. Using a heart rate monitor is best.
2. You can measure manually, post-exercise, as long as you add a correction factor (see below). Measuring at the carotid pulse is generally most accurate, as long as you do not press too hard, which can stimulate the carotid sinus reflex and lower the heart rate.
3. The sooner you can take the measurement, the more accurate it will be.
4. A six-second or 10-second measuring period will probably be more accurate than a 15-second period because they give the heart less time to recover.
CORRECTION FACTOR IF COUNTING PULSE RATES AFTER EXERCISE
If heart rate is measured after exercise, either manually or with a heart rate monitor:
1. Add 10 beats per minute if measured within 10 seconds.
2. Add 20 beats per minute if measured after 15 seconds.
These are ballpark numbers, but you cannot expect field measurements to be exact. To get a practical read on levels of exertion, it is best to combine heart rate estimates with your own feedback on perceived exertion.
Reference: Allison DeVan, Barbara Lacy, Miriam Cortez-Cooper, Hirofumi Tanaka, Post-exercise palpation of pulse rates: its applicability to habitual exercisers Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 15:177-181, 2005.
Related Articles
How to Start Exercising the Right Way
By: Louanne Baelde | 22/10/2006 | Aerobics
The toughest part about an exercise program is getting started. The best way to start exercises is to start slow and steady. In order to change your lifestyle from sedentary to physically active, you need to have a workable plan. This article will show you how.
Patients With Patience
By: Dr. Brett Saks | 19/02/2007 | Health
We live in an on-demand society. Food, entertainment, communication-everything is at the touch of our fingertips. For many, it's increasingly difficult to appreciate a "natural process"-like the time it takes to read a good book, or to plant a vegetable garden.
We all love the conveniences, but life should never be...
Keeping Active As You Age
By: Reuben John | 25/04/2007 | Health
The keys to a healthy and happy retirement is to stay active.We might feel that since we have retired and we have done our lifelong work, we deserve to simply relax which is dangerous.
Increase your Heart Lifespan: How Daily Exercises Strengthen your Heart and Help you Lose Weight
By: Philip Rotich | 29/12/2007 | Weight Loss
Exercising daily is highly recommended by most people as a way to loss weight. Knowing the role played by the heart in this scenario will help exercise the right way and loss weight at the end. This article explains why and how exercising is an effective way to lose extra body weight.
The 3 Keys of Effective Cardio Workouts and New Fitness Programs
By: Carioteam.com Blogs | 26/03/2008 | Diseases and Conditions
Heart disease is top on many lists as the leading cause of death. Learn how you can begin an effective cardio workout program and the 3 key things you need to pay attention to as you choose your fitness program.
Reasons Why You Should Exercise
By: April Kerr | 29/03/2008 | Sports and Fitness
We often think that fitness is very trendy and all the pop and Hollywood stars are getting in on the act of yoga, pilates and spinning.
Weight Loss Foods - Worth the Weight
By: Dr. Brett Saks | 19/02/2007 | Health
Our weight weighs heavily on our minds, and it should. Approximately 127 million adults in the U.S. are overweight, 60 million obese, and 9 million severely obese says the American Obesity Association. That means two-thirds of Americans are overweight and one-third are obese. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention...
3 Heart Healthy Reasons to Start a Cardio Workout Program
By: Carioteam.com Blogs | 26/03/2008 | Wellness
There are many reasons to start a workout program to improve the ability of your heart and cardiovascular system to function. Here are just 3 reasons that are more than enough to get you off the couch and on your way to breathing easier and feeling better.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you measure business intelligence at a ...
By: brooxi | 08-07-2008
How do you measure business intelligence at a company? BI is all about measuring the KPIs for the rest of the company; how should BI measure itself?
Ten minute trainer
By: maxx | 05-07-2008
Tony Horton ten minute trainer, does it really work?
Having problems getting the Hallmark Card Studio 2008 to work...
By: Cammie | 04-07-2008
Help!! I am trying install Hallmark Card Studio 2008 and keep getting an error message that reads "This Application has failed because the application configuration is incorrect. Reinstalling the application may fix this problem." I did try reinstalling, but to no avail. The information does say you can use it with WindowsXP. I have read many comments regarding this program when I googled the problem....As I go through the installation process it tells me that the program has installed successfully, but when I try to open the program to use it I get the error message.
WATER AEROBICS - Memphis, Tennessee
By: bknd2anmls | 02-07-2008
WATER AEROBICS - Memphis, TennesseeI'm looking for a place to take water aerobics in Memphis but I want very warm water...for senior citizens who might not enjoy getting into cold water. Anyone know a place? Thanks.
Exercise
By: ivan | 01-07-2008
how much exercise should a sixty year old male do
Early morning swimming riverside county california ...
By: mayfair1981 | 01-07-2008
early morning swimming riverside county california Where are locations in Riverside County California that have public early morning swim hours?
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Sports and Fitness Articles
Thin Thighs Exercise Program
By: Richard Wooldridge | 19/07/2008
Have you ever looked at those gorgeous actresses and models and thought there's no way an average woman could ever look like that with those beautiful legs? Have you ever wondered how terrific it would be if you could sculpt a pair of sexy thin thighs like they all seem to have? Is it possible for the average woman to achieve that incredible shapely lower body that women and MEN dream about?
7 Lower Abdominal Workout Tips
By: Charles Inniss | 19/07/2008
Here are 7 tips to work your lower abdominal muscles.
Get In Shape Get That Fitness Routine
By: Amit Kheterpal | 18/07/2008
Fitness routine as most of us would understand is those fitness classes in the gym every day for one to two hours. This is the standard notion and it is correct to some extent as fitness is usually associated with working out.
Who Plays Online Bingo?
By: Simone Wright-Eddison | 18/07/2008
Whenever we think of bingo players, one image comes to mind. It might be our grandmothers and grandfathers in rocking chairs and canes socializing with people their age group while playing bingo games in a hot, stuffy and smoky bingo hall.
Thankfully online bingo is gaining popularity which smashes the image...
Bingo 101: Getting to Know the Basics of the Game
By: Simone Wright-Eddison | 18/07/2008
Bingo is a game. More specifically it is a game of chance. In playing bingo, numbers are drawn and called out and you need to match the numbers called to your bingo card. Bingo cards are numbers in grids. There are 5 columns; each column represents one letter in the...
Stimulating the Mind: Healthy Benefits of Playing Bingo
By: Paul Eddison | 18/07/2008
We live in a society that is obsessed with staying and looking young. There are a lot of diets, dietary supplements and surgery out there in the market that promises to do that for us. So what is the connection between bingo and staying young? There must be a reason...
Strategies in Playing Online Bingo
By: Simone Wright-Eddison | 18/07/2008
We all know that bingo is a game of chance. In order to win a game, you have to be lucky to do so and rely less on your technical and mental skills.
Playing bingo is quite simple. You just need to mark the called numbers on your bingo card and...
Learn the Bingo Lingo
By: Simone Wright-Eddison | 18/07/2008
As with any other game or sport, there are always certain words and terminologies that are coined by the players. These words will later catch on to other players and some of the words might even be used as a legitimate terminology to describe something that's related to the game.
If...
Sports and Fitness 
