As a college writing instructor, I can vouch that there are certain questions that come up again and again during the course of every writing class. Questions include:
When do I use "then" and when do I use "than"?
How do I write a good thesis statement?
Where do I put the page numbers?
Then there are more general questions, such as:
Do you always have to start class on time and end class on time?
Is there anyone else who teaches this course?
You're married. Really? You? (Often followed by a "That poor woman" muttered under their breath.)
But perhaps the most common question I get is whether Wikipedia, the ubiquitous online encyclopedia, can be used as a viable source for research papers. In response to this question, I try to explain how academic discourse works - I talk about accuracy, credibility, objectivity, peer-reviewing, and the like. Most of the time, students just stare at me blankly and say, "So... ah... is that a no?"
As such, I've been searching for a better response, one that I hope will finally put to rest this question, which has been lurking in the halls of academia and feeding on the unsuspecting brains of my students like a zombie from one of the old Simpson's Halloween Specials. At long last, I think I finally found the answer, which was provided by, of all people, the founder of Wikipedia.com, Jimmy Wales. To quote from The Chronicle of Higher Education:
Speaking at a conference at the University of Pennsylvania on Friday called "The Hyperlinked Society," Mr. Wales said that he gets about 10 e-mail messages a week from students who complain that Wikipedia has gotten them into academic hot water. "They say, 'Please help me. I got an F on my paper because I cited Wikipedia'" and the information turned out to be wrong, he says. But he said he has no sympathy for their plight, noting that he thinks to himself: "For God sake, you're in college; don't cite the encyclopedia."
Mr. Wales goes on to say that Wikipedia is good for getting a general overview for a subject but notes that academic papers should draw from real sources - you know, like the kind you find in the library.
There it is - straight from the horse's mouth - Wikipedia is not a viable source for college papers. Thus, I think it's finally time that students and educators accept the fact that serious academic discussions must be conducted in serious academic forums. Websites like Wikipedia simply cannot function as the means for conveying crucial information on scholarly topics.
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
How are the images taken?
By: Jess | 23-07-2008
I was just looking at google map. How the heck are theses pictures taken? I just looked at a picture of my house that I know is about 6 months old. I got the man to walk up and down my block and everything.I dont remember a man walking around with a camera. My husband says its satallite. Well how the heck do they get the pictures??
Does the 30 grace period apply to a J-2 visa ...
By: fsn | 23-07-2008
does the 30 grace period apply to a J-2 visa holder?
Does magnet h2o systems work
By: Robert | 23-07-2008
does magnet h2o systems work
Hesburgh-rockefeller birth control meetings at notre dame
By: Robert Baumgartner | 23-07-2008
Please send me any info on Theodore Hesburgh's secret meetings on birth control with John D. Rockefeller III at the Notre Dame campus in the 1960s. Thank you, Robert
Father Herburgh and John D. Rockefeller's secret meetings on Contraception
By: Robert Baumgartner | 23-07-2008
I would like anything you can get me on Theodore Hesburgh, John D. Rockefeller, and the secret meetings at Notre Dame on contraception and birth control. Thank you
Is my earnings in UK mandatory for my spouse visa?
By: Srni | 23-07-2008
I am arrived in UK a week ago on HSMP and searching for a job. Now I want my spouse to apply for dependent visa to join me in UK. I learnt from somebody that I must show my earning in UK and bank statement stuff like that to apply for my spouse's visa. I have required funds in my account in India on my name GBP2800+1600. Can you please guide me?
Q&A Powered by:
Latest Writing Articles
Can a Tsunami Strike the Atlantic Coast?
By: Gordon Gumpertz | 11/10/2008
Can a tsunami strike the coast of New Jersey, North Carolina, or Florida? The question crossed my mind as I was doing research for my action/adventure novel TSUNAMI, even though the book is set in the Pacific.
The answer is yes, a tsunami hitting the Atlantic Coast is possible, but...
Book Review: 3 Aces by Richard Ide
By: Simon Barrett | 10/10/2008
One of the great joys of being a book reviewer is that you never know what is going to turn up in your mail box. There are so many great new writers out there. In fact I have a confession to make, did you know that you could take me...
Write For The Money
By: Ruth Barringham | 09/10/2008
Some purists will try and tell you that writing is an art form and that all artists should work only for the love and fulfilment that their talent brings them.
But I say that's rubbish. If you want to be a successful and wealthy writer, then you need to write for...
Why You Should Enter Contests
By: Deborah Owen | 09/10/2008
I'll never forget my first contest. It was the Writer's Digest contest. I was very naïve at the time, not understanding that there would be thousands upon thousands of entries. I had grossly underestimated what I was up against. But truth be known, if I had seen a contest advertised...
Five Mistakes to Avoid When Writing for Kids
By: Emma Walton Hamilton | 08/10/2008
The five most common mistakes to avoid when writing books for children of all ages.
5 Steps to Writing a Better Article and Getting More Traffic From it
By: Jeff Schuman | 08/10/2008
One of the most highly recommended internet tools that you can use to generate traffic is article marketing. Here's how you can get more traffic with article marketing:
Your Readers Love to Read About Tension Between Your Characters
By: Mervyn Love | 07/10/2008
Tension is inextricably bound up in the emotions of your characters, and by introducing tension you lead your readers into the same emotions, as they 'feel' for the characters in your story.
How to Work Out the ROI on Your Audio Book Promotions?
By: Stephanie Ciccarelli | 06/10/2008
When you hire a voice talent for an audiobook promotion, let's say for a national radio commercial, have you ever measured the return on investment that you received from the radio campaign? This article is about how to do that - for any voice over project.
More from Ben Welch
The Connection Between Antioxidants and Improved Health
By: Ben Welch | 10/08/2008 | Nutrition
"Antioxidant" is the term for a group of nutrients with many health-promoting properties. They are found in raw foods and are associated with many desirable qualities from better eyesight to possible cancer prevention.
Why All the Hype About an Itty-Bitty Berry?
By: Ben Welch | 04/08/2008 | Nutrition
The acai berry can do a number of things to improve your health, reduce aging, decrease likelihood of cancer and increase your energy. Is it just too good to be true? Or does this little berry keep its promises?
Illiterate America: An Epidemic of Bad English
By: Ben Welch | 17/05/2008 | Communication
Bad English is spreading like a plague. Recently, its spread is being fueled by an army of illiterates taking to the internet and text messaging. We, as Americans, do okay when we have a script off of which to read (i.e. presidential speeches, Oscar acceptance speeches). Anytime someone is off the script, however, watch for their English to fall apart like a house of rice paper cards.
School is Addictive! The Thrill of Learning and Discovery
By: Ben Welch | 12/05/2008 | Education
School can become addictive. Despite all the hardships required, the thrill of learning, discovering, and being challenged can become pretty enjoyable. Talking with educated people and talking about theories and philosophies can become a stimulant - simply put, addictive.
Get the Most Out of Medicare in 2008
By: Ben Welch | 26/04/2008 | Health
Learn how to make the most of your Medicare coverage this year.
Yes, You Can (and Should!) Still Exercise
By: Ben Welch | 10/04/2008 | Health
The benefits of exercise are wide-reaching, and well-known. But what if you're in a wheelchair or have limited mobility due to injury or disease? Should you still exercise regularly?
Medicare Open Enrollment: Which Plan is Right For You?
By: Ben Welch | 12/03/2008 | Health
It's February again, and the millions of Americans who are currently on Medicare know what this season means: the time for open enrollment is quickly running out. Find out which plan is right for you.
Financial Aid for College: Several Promising Signs
By: Ben Welch | 31/07/2007 | Non-Fiction
Even with the rising cost of education, there are several promising signs for college students (and their parents).
Writing 
