 |
Practices Deleterious To Both Reader And Author
Author: John H. Manhold  | Posted: 10-05-2008 | Comments: 0 | Views: 2 | Rating: (140)  (?) 
In the April issue of Roundup Magazine, W. C. Jameson, the author of several books and a just published novel, discussed at some length "The Honesty of Blurbs." He cited numerous examples of how these comments printed on the book jacket, or back cover of paperbacks, most frequently were 'dishonest.'
Among his examples, were the author who asked for a blurb, and was surprised that the person whom he had asked, wanted to read the book; a blurb that was delivered to the author at his request, rather than the publisher, and appeared in press as a much altered, and improved version of the original; of publishers who admitted that blurbs they applied to books frequently, were written for them at their request, by another of their authors. Many readers do not depend upon these blurbs in selecting a book. However, if they do, I must concur with Jameson's conclusions that the reader may or may not receive an accurate evaluation.
There is another matter that is just as dishonest to the reader and, perhaps, even more dishonest and detrimental, to the author and publisher. This is the book review done by a reviewer who, for one reason or another, does not really read the book. We all are aware that one can read at many levels - while also watching television, while half-asleep, as an assigned chore, or for actual personal enjoyment. Each attention method, obviously, would produce a different review.
Over a number of years I have had, as an author, more than a hundred research papers, as well as six textbooks, a lexicon in four languages, and a recently published novel, all subject to review. In no way, have I been able to find fault with most of the reviews, and have complete respect for the reviewers' opinions.
In the recent past, I have found an increased level of annoyance with reviews, however. I have read several novels that are not as reviewed. Too often, it appears that the reviewer has been participating in some of the activities sited above while reading the book in hand. His evaluation may result from an undesirable assignment, or has come about in some other unpleasant manner. Regardless of cause, results usually take the form of criticism of historical fact, when the fact is there, but the reviewer missed it. Or, there may be criticism of a character's language or actions that contain thinly veiled sarcasm. Or again, the reviewer may not be compatible with the book, and instead of providing a truthful overview, will again resort to criticism. Regardless, I have found the review erroneous, and of little help in a pre-evaluation of the book.
It is true, that it is not an easy task to provide an unbiased review, if one or more factors result in book-reader incompatibility. However, a reviewer, in such circumstances, is doing a disservice to the editor, the author and the reader, and should turn the task over to another.
As an editor of a scientific journal for a number of years, I provided almost countless papers and books to reviewers. Reviews are a requirement for the health of science. I believe they serve a similar purpose for the health of material provided for enjoyment. As an editor, I always expected a reviewer to read a book, or paper carefully. If they could not equate, they merely informed me and I would assign it to another.
One can postulate that application of the same policy to pleasurable reading that one applies to scientific books and papers is too stringent. However, the cost of publishing and purchasing books today is far more expensive. Nicely bound paperbacks easily reach the fourteen to sixteen dollar range. Would it not seem appropriate to at least provide an honest evaluation for a reader, and incidentally give the author and its publisher a break?
The book ratings that the reader provides in passing, such as those by Amazon readers, have no alternative but to be accepted for what they are. But, parenthetically, usually they are quite accurate. On the other hand, would it be too much trouble for editors and publishers who request reviews, to be a little more careful in their handling of reviews and reviewers? Incorrect, or badly done, reviews can be bad for all levels of the industry. Done correctly, they are helpful to all.
Rate this Article:
Current: 0 / 5 stars - 0 vote(s).
Article Source: http://www.articlesbase.com/writing-articles/practices-deleterious-to-both-reader-and-author-409849.html
About the Author:John H. Manhold is a retired professor and scientific journal editor. He is an author of several textbooks, a lexicon in four languages and now novels that often require extensive research. He provides coaching on various types and phases of writing. Please see John Manhold for more information, and an address.
|
Submitting articles has become one of the most popular means of generating quality backlinks and targeted traffic to your website. Join us today - It's Free! |
|
Related Articles
Book Review: El Tigre by John H. Manhold
By: Simon Barrett | 04/07/2008 | Writing
There are two very different schools of thought about historical fiction. One school rationalizes that it is an easy genre to write, the plot already exists, all you have to do is put it in your own words. The second school says that this genre is very hard to work...
Book Review: Dancing Above The Waves By Susan Walerstein
By: Simon Barrett | 28/05/2008 | Writing
Jack 'Scooter' McAlister gives the world the impression that he has it all, this Bostonian businessman exudes wealth and success. But is it real? His magazine business is not doing as well as it could, and the problems of jiggling a wife and a mistress, are wearing thin on him....
Book Review: Unholy Domain by Dan Ronco
By: Simon Barrett | 04/07/2008 | Writing
There are a plethora of sci-fi books that have explored what the Earth would be like after the apocalypse, and generally the apocalypse in question is a nuclear war, or some sort of plague.
Unholy Domain takes this genre in a new and very thought provoking direction. One only has to...
Internet Authors Live in the Present
By: Mike Scantlebury | 31/08/2007 | Writing
Bad day? If you're already feeling bad, it's hard enough to cope with the 'here and now'. And who knows what disasters tomorrow may bring? Talk to Mike Scantlebury and hear why it's a good idea to 'pick yourself up' and start again, but even better to brush off the dust of defeat as well as keeping your head out of the clouds of what might be coming. (It might not.) Let's talk about 'now'. What can we do - today?
Alternatives to Books
By: Mike Scantlebury | 26/10/2007 | Writing
Why are people so dense? Why won't they do what's good for them? Men in white coats have been sweating in labs for many years to invent the perfect e-book reader, so why aren't they everyhwere? Why can't people just ditch those smelly, crumbly, rotting woody things called 'books' and start living in Century 21? Ask author Mike Scantlebury and see if he has any suggestions.
Researching The Historical Novel, Part I
By: John H. Manhold | 24/05/2008 | Writing
As I have intimated in previous offerings, the research that goes into writing a historical novel can be almost minimal, or can entail weeks and months of endeavor. If one wishes to write about something as remote as the caravans carrying silk in the ancient days over the Silk Road...
Seven Things Authors Must Know to Be Successful
By: Jerry D. Simmons | 16/06/2008 | Writing
Publishing is a very competitive business and the choices for getting a manuscript into print are numerous. Everyone who writes has to make a decision on what's best for them and their manuscript or book, but the decision should be based on their personal goals and not what someone else...
Self-Publishing The Hard Way: The Art Of Giving Birth
By: Dodie Cross | 31/10/2007 | Writing
You know? When you publish a book and send it out into the world, it's like giving birth to a baby. Everyone checks out your baby. Is it breath-taking? Does it have ten toes and ten fingers? Is it pink and sweet or does it look like an extra from...
Got a Question? Ask.
Ask the community a question about this article:
Frequently Asked Questions
Saving My Font Prefererences
By: Nan | 07-07-2008
Since the last AOL upgrade, I've successfully figured out how to create a personal font size and color when composing emails but have lost the ability to SAVE these settings. As it now stands, I am forced to set font style, size, and color for each outgoing email. Any way to save my preferences? Thanks! NF
Finding original writings of William Sywgard
By: prita | 06-07-2008
I am looking for Awareness Techniques Book 1 by William Swygard . I have Book 2 and am interested in any of the original writings Can someone help??
The Town of Dipsy Doodle
By: msbetty | 05-07-2008
Is the Tom Thumb Book "The Town of Dipsy Doodle still under copy right? It was originally published by Rand McNally & Company in MCMXLX.
Tassahara hotsprings
By: reimerconstruct | 03-07-2008
I'd like to know who has knowledge of ernie gann's visits to tassahara hotsprings, The place My grandparents owned and operated.
Authors putting up ads on answers.
By: Ki | 02-07-2008
Why are there authors trying to sell their books here? It doesn't help the people in the questions if all you're giving for an answer is an ad for your book. Does anyone else notice this?
How much is 1780 deed book monmouth worth
By: buckler53 | 01-07-2008
how much is 1780 deed book monmouth worth
Q&A Powered by: 
More from John H. Manhold
More About Inserting Explanatory Text in Writing Novels
By: John H. Manhold | 16/06/2008 | Writing
In a recent article, I stated: "I found that three or four pages of explanatory text usually are quite well received." I also stated: "It may not be totally acceptable to a few readers, but overall, most will enjoy learning something new and, if the material is adequately condensed and...
Selecting A Genre In Which To Write
By: John H. Manhold | 05/06/2008 | Writing
A short time ago, I suggested to other retired workaholics the idea of attempting to write a novel. Granted, the idea was not an original one, but rather suggested to me by my wife because I was a little at loose ends after my ten to twelve-hour days began to...
Researching The Historical Novel, Part II
By: John H. Manhold | 31/05/2008 | Writing
I have mentioned previously that the Romance genre is almost a sure bet, and that mystery stories are a pretty close second. I also included adventure in the popular list, but particularly dwell on the historical novel because it not only has remained popular through the years, but recently has...
Researching The Historical Novel, Part I
By: John H. Manhold | 24/05/2008 | Writing
As I have intimated in previous offerings, the research that goes into writing a historical novel can be almost minimal, or can entail weeks and months of endeavor. If one wishes to write about something as remote as the caravans carrying silk in the ancient days over the Silk Road...
Writing The Historical Novel
By: John H. Manhold | 16/05/2008 | Writing
For many years, I had written nothing but textbooks and scientific research papers. It was my job and one that I thoroughly enjoyed. Several years ago, I retired, but remained quite active and in demand as a consultant. In the more recent past, a number of people seeking my help...
|
|
Writing 
